Key result
The 30-day postoperative death rate among 6,296 surgical patients was 1.9%, with 19.3% of deaths suspicious for an adverse event and 12.6% following an error in care.
Observational (n=6,296)
No
The 30-day postoperative death rate at a single academic center was 1.9%, with a notable proportion of deaths associated with adverse events and errors, highlighting the need for prospective audits.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Highlights preventable errors in a minority of postoperative deaths; leaves open the effect of modern perioperative safety initiatives.
OBJECTIVE: To improve understanding of perioperative deaths at an academic medical center. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: Because published data have typically focused on specific patient populations, diagnoses, or procedures, there are few data regarding surgical deaths and complications in institutional or regional studies. Specifically, surgical adverse events and errors are generally not studied comprehensively. This limits the overall understanding of complications and deaths. METHODS: Data from all operations performed in the main operating suite of the University of Virginia Health Sciences Center from January 1 to June 30, 1999, were compared with state death records to gain a dataset of patients dying within 30 days of surgery. All clinical records from patients who died were screened for adverse events and subsequently reviewed by three surgeons who identified adverse events and errors and performed comparisons with survivors. RESULTS: One hundred nineteen deaths followed 7,379 operations performed on 6,296 patients, yielding a patient death rate of 1.9%. Patients dying within 30 days of surgery were older and had higher American Society of Anesthesiologists scores. Of 119 deaths, 86 (72.3%) were attributable to the patient's primary disease. Twenty-three patient deaths (19.3% of all deaths, 0.37% of all patients) could not be attributed to the patient's primary disease and thus were suspicious for an adverse event (AE) as the cause of the death. Of the 23 deaths suspicious for AE, 15 (12.6% of all deaths, and 65.2% of AE deaths) followed an error in care and thus were classified as potentially preventable, affecting 0.24% of the study population. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, the 30-day postoperative death rate was low in the total surgical population at an academic medical center. Errors and AEs were associated with 12.6% and 19.3% of deaths, respectively. Retrospective review inadequately characterized the nature of AEs and failed to determine causality. Prospective audits of outcomes will enhance our understanding of surgical AEs.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Calland et al. (2002) conducted an observational in Surgical patients (n=6,296). Surgery was evaluated on 30-day postoperative death. The 30-day postoperative death rate among 6,296 surgical patients was 1.9%, with 19.3% of deaths suspicious for an adverse event and 12.6% following an error in care.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: