Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Introduction Across the globe, independent judiciaries are being dismantled. Not by revolution, but by law. Elected leaders invoke the language of reform, efficiency, and popular sovereignty to justify measures that, in practice, strip courts of their ability to check executive power. Methods This study examines how governments undermine judicial independence through a four-category comparative framework: the institutional capture of courts and judicial councils, the restriction of judicial powers and resources, the instrumentalisation of legal mechanisms against justice actors, and direct attacks on legal professionals. The framework is applied to a purposive sample of jurisdictions across Europe, the Americas, the Middle East, Asia, and the post-Soviet space. Results The analysis reveals that these tactics follow recognizable patterns regardless of whether they emerge in established democracies or openly authoritarian systems. Court-packing, judicial purges, budget strangulation, politically motivated prosecutions, and the criminalisation of legal advocacy happen with regularity and tend to escalate along a recognisable, if not strictly linear, sequence - gradual where institutions retain democratic stability, compressed where a crisis lowers the cost of action, and parallel where the regime is already authoritarian. Discussion The study demonstrates that the erosion of judicial independence is rarely sudden. The erosion typically unfolds incrementally and is disguised as technical legislative change, making early detection difficult and resistance politically costly. Where courts lose their independence, the constitutional order ceases to function as a meaningful constraint on power, and the distinction between democracy and autocracy becomes formal.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lilla Garayová (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: