Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Normative framework proposes foundational principles for participation governance in human-AI society.
This paper proposes the Constitution of Relationship as the normative foundation of Participation Governance. Participation Governance treats participation itself as an independent object of design, control, evaluation, and learning. The Constitution of Relationship provides the higher-order principles, limits, and responsibilities by which that participation is governed. The paper makes three structural distinctions: Protected subjects — every human being;Governed actors — entities capable of participating in human society and materially affecting humans;Object of governance — Participation and the relationships produced through it. It establishes the foundational axiom: Human status precedes human evaluation. A person’s conduct, ability, productivity, risk, social role, future potential, or wrongdoing may be evaluated. Responsibility may be imposed, freedom may be restricted, and relationships may end. Human status itself, however, may not be revoked by those evaluations. On this basis, the paper introduces three constitutional principles: Every person, whoever they are, may be prayed for until the end.A person’s future must not be closed.Proceed in the direction in which joy can grow. The first preserves the minimum relational possibility that no human being need be excluded entirely from human concern. The second constrains powerful actors from converting provisional judgments into permanent ownership of a person’s future. The third directs otherwise permissible participation toward generative joy, including agency, trust, learning, recovery, creation, question continuity, and future possibility. The paper further defines Participation Governance Responsibility through five duties: anticipatory consideration; observation; explanation; correction; and Human Return. Human Return is the substantive restoration of questions, judgment, responsibility, authority, and control while meaningful refusal, revision, or redirection remains possible. The paper also addresses finite resources, conflicting rights, punishment, relationship termination, cultural localization, self-binding, interpretation, contestation, amendment, and version control. The Constitution is presented not as a state constitution or universal lifestyle doctrine, but as the constitutional layer of Participation Governance: it governs the governance of participation. This paper is the normative companion to: Participation Governance: Governing How Powerful Systems Participate in Human Society Together, the two papers define the governance category and its highest-order normative foundation within the broader Relationship-Aware AI Research program.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
HARUKI ITO (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: