Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Investigates gene interactions affecting wing pigmentation in butterflies, suggesting evolutionary implications.
A recent preprint by Joseph Hanly and colleagues (Hanly et al., 2026 preprint) investigates the role of a recently identified long non-coding RNA, ivory, and an associated microRNA, mir-193, on wing scale development in Heliconius butterflies. The study builds on recently published work showing that: (1) ivory plays a role in melanin-based coloration on the wings of several butterfly and moth species, and (2) mir-193 mediates this effect specifically in Bicyclus anynana butterflies. Using modern genetic tools, the authors focus on how ivory and mir-193 shape wing pigmentation in Heliconius butterflies, a genus known for its spectacular color pattern mimicry, with different species and morphs converging on striking wing pigmentation to share the burden of ‘training’ predators to avoid them.The wings of lepidopteran insects, including butterflies and moths, are covered by epidermal cell projections called scales, the feature that gives this insect order its name. The pigments and ultrastructure of wing scales are jointly responsible for wing pigmentation. Their spatial arrangement on the wing surfaces can produce beautifully intricate patterns that have long captured the attention of both biologists and the general public. In recent decades, this attention and the accessibility of increasingly sophisticated genetic tools have resulted in significant advances in our understanding of the genetic basis of butterfly wing pattern development and evolution.Studies in different species and using a variety of methods have identified genes involved in the formation of wing color patterns. This process starts inside caterpillars, where wing discs grow and become compartmentalized into sections with putatively distinct color pattern fates. It is later completed in pupae, with the arrangement, formation and pigmentation of wing scales (Nijhout, 1991). As is characteristic of development more broadly (Carroll et al., 2001), studies have shown that the same ‘genetic toolkit’ is involved in the formation of what can be completely distinct color patterns in different butterfly species.Adding to the question of how color patterns are formed, and inspired by their striking diversity and known ecological functions, researchers have taken an interest in how color patterns evolve. Several studies have investigated the genetic basis of natural intra-specific variation in color patterns, which provides the raw material for natural selection to generate diversity.Although these questions are connected, asking what genes are implicated in wing pattern development is not the same as asking what genes account for intra-specific variation in wing patterns. Genes required for the development of a trait do not necessarily harbor segregating allelic variants that contribute to phenotypic variation in (natural) populations or to divergence across species. Conversely, developmental genes can provide valuable candidate loci for studies of phenotypic variation, but the actual genetic variants underlying phenotypic differences are not always immediately predictable from knowledge of gene function alone.Lepidopteran color patterns provide compelling examples of adaptive evolution, including textbook examples such as industrial melanism in the peppered moth Biston betularia and mimicry in Heliconius butterflies. In studies of natural color variants in these and other species, researchers have used linkage and association mapping, as well as genomic outlier detection, to identify genomic regions associated with color pattern variants. Interestingly, some loci repeatedly emerged across studies, supporting the idea that evolutionarily relevant variation may be disproportionately associated with particular loci. This observation, not at all unique to lepidopteran wing pattern variants, led to the concept of ‘hotspot loci’, which has become popular in evo-devo research (Martin and Orgogozo, 2013). The term draws on terminology already used in genetics, where ‘mutational hotspots’ and ‘recombination hotspots’ refer to unusually high concentrations of mutations or recombination events, respectively, in specific genomic locations.One prominent example of such a hotspot locus is the protein-coding gene cortex. Over the last couple of decades, genetic mapping studies have implicated cortex in natural pigmentation variation in several species (Nadeau et al., 2016; van't Hof et al., 2016; van der Burg et al., 2020; Livraghi et al., 2021; Wang et al., 2022; Tunström et al., 2024). More recently, work in Heliconius has identified a spontaneous mutant in a captive population in which loss of a long non-coding RNA (lncRNA) located adjacent to cortex led to the loss of melanic coloration, justifying calling this lncRNA ivory (Livraghi et al., 2024). Subsequent CRISPR-mediated loss-of-function experiments targeting ivory in multiple species supported its conserved role in melanic scale development (Fandino et al., 2024), and identified the associated microRNA (miRNA) mir-193 as the mediator of the effects of ivory on melanic scales in Bicyclus anynana (Tian et al., 2024). Together, these findings led to the speculation that ivory:mir-193 is the true causal genetic hotspot previously mapped to cortex. Even though resolution of earlier mapping studies cannot cleanly separate such closely linked regions and data on the actual causal sequence polymorphism in natural population are scarce, recent studies continue to provide evidence for a key role for this locus for wing pattern diversification across Lepidoptera (Ben Chechida et al., 2026; Liu et al., 2026).Although ivory has been identified and studied in Heliconius butterflies, mir-193 has not. The preprint by Joseph Hanly and colleagues fills this gap, investigating the relationship between ivory and mir-193 in different species and morphs of Heliconius.To test gene function, the preprint authors used CRISPR–Cas9 to induce mutations in ivory and/or mir-193, and documented changes in scale color and ultrastructure. As commonly applied in these systems, injection of sgRNAs during very early embryonic development typically generates mosaic adults, containing both wild-type and edited (crispant) clones. This mosaicism provides some key advantages, such as enabling of within-organ comparisons that are easy to inspect visually and helping to avoid complications caused by potentially lethal edits. The proportion of injections yielding crispant mosaics is generally low, but varies with target gene and sgRNA performance.By crossing mosaics that show more extensive crispant phenotypes, which may also involve edits in germline cells, researchers can generate individuals in which essentially all cells carry the knockout. Using this strategy, the authors reported altered color fates of wing scales, confirming that mir-193 knockout phenocopies effects of ivory knockout in dark melanic scales, as well as in scales containing red ommochrome pigments, though this effect was less extreme and not seen for all species analyzed.The authors also document variability in knockout effects. Determining to what extent this variability reflects differences in genetic background or variation in the specific deletions generated by CRISPR could benefit from comparing genotypes across individuals or wing sections with different phenotypes.The authors then used single nucleus RNA-seq (snRNA-seq) to investigate the transcriptional profile of developing scale cells and to compare between wild-type individuals and individuals with a deletion in the ivory:mir-193 region. Based on an existing snRNA-seq time series of developing pupal wings, the authors estimated where and when ivory is expressed, reporting strong ivory expression specifically in scale precursor cells. This contrasts with earlier bulk RNA-seq results that detected low wing-wide ivory signal (Livraghi et al., 2024) and highlights the benefits of snRNA-seq for detecting transcripts beyond the processed mRNAs that dominate the cytoplasmic component captured by bulk RNA-seq. Ideally, such expression dynamics could be further linked to spatial patterning using approaches such as HCR (hybridization chain reaction) to map ivory expression directly onto the developing wing regions corresponding to natural color pattern variants.Analysis of what genes are co-expressed with ivory and change expression upon deletion of that locus allowed the authors to generate hypotheses about possible upstream regulators and downstream targets of ivory. Disentangling how the ivory:mir-193 module connects upstream expression to downstream pigmentation outcomes remains a major opportunity. Detailed temporal and combinatorial comparisons across ivory:mir-193 genotypes could help clarify which expression changes reflect early patterning decisions versus later pigmentation execution.The work on ivory displayed in the preprint by Joseph Hanly and colleagues underscores how natural variation in lncRNAs and miRNAs might contribute to phenotypic differences, and how miRNA-mediated gene regulation can produce repeatable changes in morphology.More broadly, this preprint fits into evo-devo's quest to characterize the nature and function of the genetic variants contributing to evolutionarily relevant phenotypic differences. This includes identifying and characterizing the underlying loci and specific nucleotide changes, including whether particular genes (hotspot loci), molecular functions (e.g. transcription factors versus enzymes) and gene regions (e.g. coding versus regulatory, and, among the latter, cis-regulatory elements versus regulatory miRNAs) are disproportionally represented in the pool of genetic variation that contributes to adaptive phenotypic variation within species, and to phenotypic diversification across species.I thank Reinier Prosée for guidance and helpful suggestions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Patrícia Beldade (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: