Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The rise of artificial intelligence (AI) has often been accompanied by its characterization as a “wicked issue.” This paper subjects that claim to critical analysis, arguing that it is a misdiagnosis. The analysis shows that the problems associated with AI do not exhibit the defining attributes of wicked issues, such as irresolvable value conflicts, non‐linear interdependencies, or the absence of workable solutions. They are better understood as complicated yet tractable policy challenges. The misdiagnosis is sustained by conceptual overstretching, technological mystification, and possibly framing by actors with interests in permissive regulatory outcomes. By challenging the conventional wisdom on the wickedness of AI, the paper sharpens the analytical use of the wicked‐issue concept and contributes to a more grounded debate on the governance of emerging technologies. It further distinguishes the governance of AI systems from economy‐wide adaptation to technological change, showing that while such adaptation is difficult, it is tractable and does not, in itself, warrant a “wicked” label. The findings contribute to three main strands of scholarship: first, the wicked‐issue literature, by identifying technological mystification as a specific mechanism of over‐diagnosis; second, the regulatory governance literature, by pointing to the implications of (non) wicked labelling for emerging regulatory models; and third, the policy‐framing literature, by showing how the wickedness frame constrains the perceived scope for governance action.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tomić et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: