Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Perceptual categorization requires mapping highly variable sensory signals onto the same category. Some items are clearer examples of the category, being more typical or more distinct from contrasting categories. As a result, individual items differ in the difficulty and effort it takes to categorize them correctly – easier exemplars are more quickly and accurately identified and are therefore less effortful (and difficult exemplars are more effortful). Here, we ask how learners balance effort with reward when learning new categories. We examine rule-based auditory category learning with stimuli varying in the effort required for correct categorization. Three conditions varied in how effort was aligned with reward – high reward for high effort, high reward for low effort, and random reward. We compared results when participants learned from experience, actively exerting effort themselves to learn the categories (Experiment 1) and when participants learned from observing the effortful actions and outcomes of another learner (Experiment 2). Surprisingly, we found that aligning effort and reward was not beneficial for learning and that participants learned the categories and generalized to novel instances regardless of whether they learned through experience or observation. Further, participants only learned the incidental relationship between effort and reward when they learned through experience. When learning through observation, participants defaulted to an expectation that high effort should yield high reward, regardless of the relationship they actually experienced. Overall, generalization of category knowledge is possible through either experiential or observational learning but adjusting expectations about the relationship between effort and reward requires learning from experience.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Roark et al. (2024) studied this question.