This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Johansen et al. have commented on our recent publication in the Journal concerning cancer incidence in Israeli Jewish survivors of World War II (WWII) and on the accompanying editorial. They indicate that psychological stress per se is not a promising explanation for cancer occurrence and disagree with our conclusions that it may, at least partly, account for the study results. We are in agreement with Johansen et al. regarding the fact that to date mental stress has not been established as a risk factor for cancer incidence. In fact, we had such a statement in our article: “The few studies that investigated the association between psychological stress and cancer incidence in various populations have reached inconclusive results.” We do think, though, that mental stress may play an indirect role in cancer incidence through other mechanisms, such as “adoption of certain lifestyles or behaviors that have been associated with increased cancer risk (eg, higher smoking or obesity rates),” and/or through long-standing WWII-related posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), which may also contribute to higher cancer risk through similar mechanisms. Jewish WWII survivors do have higher PTSD rates than age-matched, nonexposed control subjects ( 1 , 2 ), and PTSD has been associated with higher tobacco dependence ( 3 ) and substance use ( 4 ). To the best of our knowledge, there are no publications to date assessing the association between PTSD and cancer incidence. We agree with Johansen et al. that a more promising explanation for the results observed may be the prolonged exposure to calorie restriction during the WWII. Although not supported by the editorial by Hursting and Forman, we believe that the human exposure to extreme but transient calorie restriction, especially when unbalanced in terms of macronutrients, is very different from the experimental exposure of laboratory animals to a well-balanced, lifelong, calorie-restricted diet and may thus cause very different results. In fact, when rats had been exposed to a calorie-restricted diet for a short period after weaning and then fed ad libitum for the rest of their lives, they had an increased risk of malignant cancer later in life compared with rats that were fed ad libitum throughout life ( 5 ). Some of the human studies cited in our article, referring to a severe but transient calorie restriction followed by nonrestricted diet, imply similar findings. Additionally, the possibility of a synergism between the extreme calorie restriction and the mental stress (and possibly other extreme exposures) experienced by those surviving WWII may also account—at least partly—for the observed results. In at least one publication, extreme life-threatening calorie restriction was associated with high rates of subsequent PTSD ( 6 ). Because no specific data are available to date on the potential outcomes of such synergism, these questions remain to be further explored.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Keinan-Boker et al. (2010) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: