Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
‘The health of people around the world is at the mercy of a persistent fossil fuel addiction’, these are the damning words of the 2022 Global Report of the Lancet Countdown.1 Over the past 50 years alone there has been a fivefold increase in the number of recorded weather-related disasters; the frequency and severity of which are predicted to rise.2 Extreme weather events will continue to decimate communities, leaving hundreds of thousands displaced and vulnerable. The healthcare sector must recognise its role in contributing to carbon emissions and commit to taking decisive action to reduce these. Globally healthcare sectors are in a paradox of requiring increased investment to mitigate the health effects of climate warming, whilst also contributing significantly to the worlds carbon footprint. A 2021 report by the Lancet estimated that globally the healthcare sector contributes to 4.9% of greenhouse gas emissions.3 As the impact of these numbers are coming to a fore, sustainable healthcare is becoming a necessity. This study aimed to determine the reduction in CO2e from same-day surgery for patients seen at skin cancer clinics. CO2e from travel by patients undergoing surgical procedures during a 6-month period (July to December 2020 inclusive), were calculated. Data collected included age, diagnosis, site of lesion and total number of visits. The distance from the patient's address was calculated using Google Maps. Total CO2e was calculated using an online calculator recommended by the Environmental Protection Agency of Ireland.4 A total of 299 patients had 360 procedures between July and December 2020. The mean patient age was 64 (range 16–97 years). Basal cell carcinoma was the most common diagnosis (28.5%). Forty-six (12.9%) naevi of differing subtypes were excised including compound, junctional, blue, and spitz naevi (Table 1). Dermatological surgery was defined as procedures that required a surgical theatre including excision, biopsy, shave excision and curettage and cautery (Table 2). The total distance travelled by patients was 26,069 km, generating 4.47 tonnes of CO2e emissions. 75% of patients opted to have surgery on the same day as their clinic appointment. They travelled a mean distance of 73 (range 1.2–464 km) with a mean of 1 hospital visit (range 1–2). A further 25% of patients had alternative day surgery travelling a mean distance of 128 (range 8.4–789 km) with a mean of two hospital visits (range 1–5). Reasons for same-day surgery not being selected included patient preference, anticoagulation (such as warfarin) and capacity issues within the department. The mean CO2e for patients attending for same-day procedures was 0.017 tonnes compared with 0.024 tonnes for alternate-day procedures; a reduction of 0.007 tonnes or 30% per patient (p = 0.3). The introduction of same-day surgery for patients resulted in a 2.93 tonne (55%) reduction in CO2e. This is equivalent to driving from the North to the South of Ireland 13 times (8000 km) (Figure 1). Over 50 countries, including the United Kingdom and Ireland have made sustainable commitments through the COP-26 Health programme. This involves commitments to climate-resilient healthcare, including carbon emission reduction and net-zero health systems by 2050.5 Defining the role of individual healthcare departments in what is now a well-established global crisis is extremely challenging, however small changes made by individuals can certainly bring about a positive, often dramatic change. Same-day surgery for skin cancer patients has several positive benefits; prompt management of suspicious skin lesions, less time spent attending hospital for patients and their carers and reduced anxiety anticipating alternative day procedures. We have demonstrated a reproducible, additional benefit; the reduction of the carbon footprint generated by skin cancer management. With ever increasing demands on the healthcare system, it is vital that we use innovative ways to reduce the carbon footprint generated. The actions of healthcare sector now will affect the health and wellbeing of generations to come. clinical dermatology, cutaneous neoplasms, cutaneous surgery, dermatologicsurgery Blaithin Moriarty and Aoife Lally conceived and planned the project. They were both involved in editing the final manuscript and supervision of the project. Sarah Fleming was involved in data collection and analysis, writing of the report and editing of draughts. Sarah Fleming is corresponding author. Ciara Drumm was involved in data analysis, editing of draughts and supervising the project. Sorcha Lynch and Ciara Donnell were involved in data collection. The authors declare no conflict of interest. The authors have nothing to report. The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fleming et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: