Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Summary Underground hydrogen storage (UHS) can be a valuable solution for efficient and environmentally friendly energy storage but it introduces complex microbial and geochemical interactions that pose unique challenges. This research leverages advanced biogeochemical modeling to accurately replicate these interactions, reproduced within a laboratory-scale bioreactor system that mimics the high-pressure and high-temperature conditions typical of many underground gas storages. Utilizing a dual-platform approach, we used COMSOL® Multiphysics and CMG-GEM, augmented by supplementary simulation tools like PHREEQC, to perform an in-depth analysis of the evolution of microbial populations and gas and liquid composition, and of the hydrochemical processes in geological formations. Our comparative study demonstrates the effective application of these platforms in modeling the complex dynamics of heat and fluid dynamics, mass transfer, and biochemical reactions. The models were meticulously validated against experimental data, displaying high accuracy in kinetic parameter fitting and the ability to replicate the observed phenomena, including microbial hydrogen consumption rates below 0.05% under specified conditions and no detectable H₂S production at high pressures. The simulation results from COMSOL® and CMG-GEM showed remarkable agreement, with differences in the respective outcomes under 3–5%, confirming the reliability and robustness of the simulations across different computational environments. The research highlights the benefits of integrating multiple simulation platforms to achieve a comprehensive and comparative understanding of biogeochemical processes at various scales. This approach not only enhances our predictive capabilities but also facilitates the transfer of biochemical and geochemical kinetics from bioreactor-scale to reservoir-scale models, to make the implementation of hydrogen storage possible. These findings underscore the potential of the modeling tools to support the assessment and management of microbial risks associated with hydrogen storage, contributing to fully assessing the storage feasibility. By providing a detailed comparison of two leading software platforms, we established an essential methodological framework for advancing the UHS technology toward safe implementation.
Vasile et al. (Mon,) studied this question.