Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Study analyzed NDVI relationships in Scots pine forests, suggesting variability based on regional and moisture factors.
Satellite-derived vegetation indices are widely used in forest monitoring, yet their interpretation is complicated by the fact that canopy reflectance integrates both environmental stress signals and structural variation in stands. This challenge is particularly important across broad ecological gradients, where relationships between optical metrics and stand attributes may be spatially non-stationary. Here, we analysed NDVI–stand structure relationships in Scots pine-dominated forests across the whole of Poland using 30 m HLSS30 imagery, LiDAR-derived stand metrics, and a Geographic Gaussian Process Generalised Additive Model (GGP-GAM). The study focused on closed-canopy, undisturbed Scots pine stands and examined annual NDVI variation in 2016–2022 across eight forest natural regions in relation to stand age, stand volume, top height, and the Relative Spacing Index (RSI). Mean NDVI showed persistent regional differentiation across Poland and ranged from 0.64 to 0.84. The proportion of NDVI variability explained by stand characteristics varied markedly among years and forest natural regions, indicating strong spatial and temporal heterogeneity in NDVI–structure relationships. In general, structural predictors explained a larger share of NDVI variation in years with more favourable moisture conditions, whereas in drought years this structural signal was less apparent, partly coinciding with lower and more compressed NDVI distributions. An illustrative regional analysis further showed that the direction and magnitude of the partial effects of stand attributes changed among years, demonstrating that the structural meaning of NDVI was not constant through time. The results show that NDVI should not be interpreted as a spatially invariant proxy of stand structure across heterogeneous forest landscapes. Instead, its information content depends on both regional context and annual moisture conditions. By combining harmonized optical time series, LiDAR-derived stand descriptors and spatially varying modelling, this study provides a framework for more robust interpretation of canopy greenness in large-area forest monitoring.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tymińska-Czabańska et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: