Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Previous studies have primarily focused on the objective characteristics of policy tools while overlooking the influence of citizens' psychological construction of those tools on their effectiveness in promoting policy compliance. Construal level theory posits that individuals' response to an event or object depends on how they mentally construe it, which is shaped by the psychological distance they perceive. Drawing on this theoretical insight, this study examines whether and how citizen perceived psychological distance (including temporal, spatial, social, and hypothetical distance) toward policy tools of reward and punishment affects their effectiveness in encouraging compliance willingness. Through four survey experiments conducted in the context of China's waste‐sorting policy, the findings revealed that: (1) overall, reward was more effective than punishment in promoting compliance willingness; (2) when reward was perceived as psychologically proximal, its effect on compliance was significantly stronger than when it was perceived as distant, whereas the effect of punishment remained almost unaffected by psychological distance; and (3) as psychological distance increased, the relative advantage of reward over punishment disappeared. These findings reveal that the effectiveness of reward and punishment is influenced by the citizens' psychological construal of them, therefore offering a psychological approach beyond instrument‐level adjustments for enhancing the effectiveness of policy tools in promoting citizen compliance.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Zhang et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: