Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Relative weight (Wr) is 100 × W/Ws, W being the weight of an individual fish and W the “standard” weight of a fish of the same length. The widespread application of relative weight in fisheries management has been hindered by the slow development of standard weights at length for many important fish species. We found the conventional approach to Ws development to be limited by data availability and improperly influenced by sample weighting. We designed and tested a method of Ws development that addresses these shortcomings. Our method treats log10weight-log10length regression equations for a series of a species' populations as the statistical population to be modeled. First, we predict mean fish weight in 1-cm total length intervals for each population. Then we find the 75th percentile of the mean weights in each interval, and regress these on length to determine the parameters for the Ws equation. Standard-weight equations determined by our regression-line-percentile (RLP) technique were functionally equivalent to published equations for several species tested. We then used the RLP technique to develop Ws equations for walleye Stizostedion vitreum based on 114 site-specific weight-length regressions for 42,487 fish from across North America. The metric equation is log10 Ws (g) = −5.453 + 3.180 log10total length (mm). The English-unit equation is log10 Ws (lb) = −3.642 + 3.180 log10total length (in). There was no important influence of fish length on Wr values calculated with these equations. Neither proportional nor relative stock densities of walleyes were correlated meaningfully with Wr. Confidence interval width for mean Wr in walleye populations is directly predictable from sample size because sample variance is independent of sample size. “Desirable” mean Wr target values (100 ± 5) were achieved by approximately one quarter of the lakes in our sample. The RLP technique appears to be a viable approach to the development of Ws relationships that should speed and improve the application of Wr theory to important fish species.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Murphy et al. (1990) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: