Key result
Five creatinine clearance estimation methods failed to accurately predict measured creatinine clearance in morbidly obese patients, with IBW methods underestimating and TBW methods overestimating.
Why the study?
Do standard estimation methods accurately predict measured creatinine clearance in morbidly obese patients?
Observational (n=43)
Do standard estimation methods accurately predict measured creatinine clearance in morbidly obese patients?
Standard methods for estimating creatinine clearance are inaccurate in morbidly obese patients, either significantly underestimating or overestimating true clearance depending on the weight metric used.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Caution advised dosing morbidly obese patients by Clcr estimates; leaves open optimal method for validation.
Estimates of creatinine clearance (Clcr), using five methods, were compared to measured Clcr in morbidity obese patients. Patients whose total body weight (TBW) was greater than or equal to 195% of their ideal body weight (IBW) and who had urinary Clcr measured with 24-hour urine collections were studied. The 12 men weighed an average of 180 kg; the 31 women averaged 138 kg. The methods studied considered a combination of the following factors: weight, age, sex, and serum creatinine. One method was a nomogram; TBW could not be used because of limitations of the nomogram. Both TBW and IBW were used in two methods that considered weight as a variable. Measured Clcr averaged 105.7 ml/min/1.73 sq m body surface area. All estimating methods using IBW significantly underestimated Clcr; all methods using TBW significantly overestimated Clcr. Two methods that did not include body weight as a variable predicted Clcr more accurately than did other methods, but there was still a significant difference between estimated and measured Clcr. None of the Clcr estimation methods is accurate in morbidly obese patients.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Dionne et al. (1981) conducted an observational in Morbid obesity (n=43). Creatinine clearance estimation methods vs. Measured 24-hour urinary creatinine clearance was evaluated on Accuracy of estimated creatinine clearance compared to measured creatinine clearance. Five creatinine clearance estimation methods failed to accurately predict measured creatinine clearance in morbidly obese patients, with IBW methods underestimating and TBW methods overestimating.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: