Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Sugar beet ( Beta vulgaris ) is an important cash crop grown in temperate regions to produce sugar. Fungal leaf diseases are known to infect the sugar beet crop during the season, causing significant yield reductions. This study aimed to investigate the effect of biological control agents and sulphur on disease control and yield, regarded as alternatives to conventional synthetic fungicides. Ten field trials were carried out between 2016 and 2020. The study focused on control of powdery mildew ( Erysiphe betae ) and beet rust ( Uromyces betae ). In six field trials, the impact of the BCA product (Serenade® ASO) was compared using two to four applications. The BCA was applied either repeatedly as a solo product or within an IPM strategy combined with conventional fungicides. A second series of four field trials tested sulphur and Serenade® ASO as solo solutions compared with chemical solutions and in combination with the chemical solutions. Traditional fungicides using two applications gave 76–99 % (avg. 88 %) control of powdery mildew and 59–100 % (avg. 78 %) control of leaf rust (based on AUDPC) and 3.1–9.8 t/ha root yield increases. Serenade® ASO applied as a solo product at 1–4 timings gave a lower and more variable effect of 0–66 % (avg. 20 %) against powdery mildew and 0–30 % (avg. 14 %) against rust, but these were not statistically significant. Root yield increases ranging from 0–6.6 t/ha were observed with Serenade® ASO, though these were not statistically significant. No substantial effect was seen from changing the dose or number of treatments with Serenade® ASO. When applied as part of a spraying programme in conjunction with traditional chemistry, no clear benefit could be measured in terms of either disease control or yield responses compared to using traditional fungicides alone. A greenhouse trial indicated verification that the earlier timing using Serenade® ASO was more effective and gave indications of a dose effect. Sulphur used as a solo solution gave significant control of powdery mildew in line with chemical substances (avg. 78 %), but statistically non-significant root yield increases of 2.4–11.5 t/ha, and inferior control of rust compared to chemical solutions. In an IPM context, sulphur could replace chemical treatments for control of powdery mildew while this was not the case for Serenade® ASO. Neither could replace rust control with traditional chemistries.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Heick et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: