This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Otitis media is the most common disease seen in pediatric practice in the United States. There is growing evidence that not all cases of acute otitis media (AOM) require antibiotic treatment, because many children with mild AOM recover spontaneously.1 However, empiric antibiotic therapy is still the mainstay of treatment in many countries. Widespread antibiotic use has led to development of bacterial antibiotic resistance. Studies have demonstrated that bacterial pathogens can revert to nonresistance in communities where antibiotic use is curtailed.2 Experts have recommended more judicious use of antibiotics, and a large campaign to reduce antibiotic use has been mounted by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.3 Clinicians have begun to limit antibiotic use for mild cases of AOM,4 but there is little information on how the clinician should select patients who might benefit from delayed or withheld antibiotic treatment. Evidence gleaned from published articles suggests that clinical signs and symptoms of AOM may be associated with specific bacterial pathogens. Coffey5 reported an association of Streptococcus pneumoniae with bullous myringitis. Howie et al.6 reported more pain and fever in children with pneumococcal AOM. Rodriguez and Schwartz7 described higher fever and more intensely yellow/red and bulging tympanic membranes (TMs) in AOM associated with S. pneumoniae. Less is known about the appearance of viral AOM, even though respiratory viruses can be isolated from as many as 17% of children with AOM.8 The aim of this study was to determine whether signs and symptoms of AOM might be correlated with the presence of bacterial or viral pathogens in the middle ear fluid. If viral AOM could be diagnosed from clinical data, then the clinician might be able to avoid prescribing antibiotics for some children with AOM. Methods. Patient assessment. We enrolled children with AOM from the pediatric clinic for a study of adjuvant therapy in the treatment of AOM (results to be reported later). Data included in this report were gathered at enrollment and on Days 3 to 5 postenrollment. We included children if they had a clinical diagnosis of AOM and if the parent had signed an informed consent approved by our institutional review board. Children were excluded if they had defects of the ear or nasopharynx, a major medical condition, antibiotic treatment for any indication within 7 days of enrollment, treatment of AOM within 30 days before enrollment or tympanostomy tubes. At each visit we asked parents to rate nine symptoms [fever, ear ache (tugging), irritability, poor feeding, rhinorrhea, nasal stuffiness, cough, sneezing and watery eyes] on a three-point Likert scale from 0 (none) to 2 (severe). The sum of these nine scores comprised the total symptom score. Because a number of nonspecific features were included in the original symptom set, we created a symptom subscore consisting of the four key features that we observed to be more specific for AOM in young children: fever (<38°C = 0, 38–39°C = 1, >39°C = 2), ear ache (none = 0, occasional = 1, frequent = 2), irritability (none = 0, occasional = 1, frequent = 2) and poor feeding (none = 0, mild = 1, severe = 2). To validate the subscore we compared pre and post scores at enrollment vs. Days 3 to 5. A difference was calculated for each subject by subtracting the post from the pre score. The combination of fever, ear ache/tugging, irritability and poor feeding proved a robust measure of change in key symptoms between enrollment and Days 3 to 5 (Visit 1 mean score = 4.44 ± 1.8, Visit 2 mean score = 0.73 ± 1.3, n = 27, Student's t test value for testing the hypothesis that the population mean was 0;P = 0.0001). A research assistant performed tympanometry using a Microaudiometrics Ear Scan tympanometer. Tympanic membranes were considered immobile if static admittance (compliance) was <0.2 ml. Using pneumatic otoscopy a physician investigator performed a physical examination to score TM appearance as follows: fullness, 0 (normal), 1 (full) or 2 (bulging); mobility, 0 (normal), 1 (decreased) or 2 (none); and color/appearance, 0 (shiny), 1 (dull/white) or 2 (yellow/red). Scores were recorded for each ear. Laboratory assessments. The investigator then performed a tympanocentesis. Middle ear and nasal wash fluids were submitted to viral and bacterial culture and rapid antigen testing according to methods previously described.8 Middle ear fluid volumes and characteristics (color, turbidity and viscosity) were recorded. Middle ear fluid was tested for respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) antigen by enzyme-linked immunoassay, and indirect fluorescent antibody staining was used to detect RSV, influenza A and B, adenoviruses and parainfluenza virus types 1, 2 and 3 in centrifuged cell pellets of nasal wash specimens. Serologic tests for the same respiratory viruses were performed by the same indirect fluorescent antibody technique. Paired acute and convalescent serum samples were tested simultaneously. Research assistants entered the data on Microsoft Excel spreadsheets on a personal computer. Data were then converted to a SAS data set, and means, percentages and standard deviations of the grouped data were calculated. Differences between groups were tested by the Wilcoxon rank sum test. Frequency distributions were analyzed by the chi square test. Differences were considered to be significant for values of P < 0.05. Results. Demographic and culture results. Eighty children were included in the study. Tympanocentesis was performed on 129 ears. Demographic data were as follows: mean age, 20.4 months (range, 3 to 74 months); 59% male; 44% African-American; 36% Caucasian; 20% Hispanic; 37% attended day care; 43% exposed to smoking at home; and 25% breast-fed. Each ear was evaluated separately, and one pathogen was isolated from 51% of ears, two pathogens from 19% and no virus or bacterial pathogen from 30%. Bacterial pathogens were detected in 50% of ears, combined bacteria and virus in 12% and virus in 7%. When each child was evaluated with both ears together, pathogens were isolated from one or both ears in the following frequency: 49% of children, bacteria only; 18% bacteria plus virus; 10% virus only; and 24% no pathogen. Bacterial pathogens isolated from middle ear fluid included S. pneumoniae (pure, 23; combined with other viral or bacterial pathogens, 16), Haemophilus influenzae (pure, 27; combined, 8), Moraxella catarrhalis (pure, 4; combined, 6) and Streptococcus pyogenes (pure, 2). Viruses were detected in 25 ears: RSV (7 virus only, 12 virus combined with other bacterial pathogens), adenovirus (1 virus only, 1 combined), rhinovirus (1 virus only), parainfluenza 3 (1 combined) and enterovirus (2 combined). Viruses were identified in nasal secretions of 23 subjects. These included RSV (4 subjects), adenovirus (5 subjects), enterovirus (1 subject), cytomegalovirus (3 subjects), parainfluenza virus (3 subjects), rhinovirus (6 subjects) and influenza virus type B (1 subject). Symptom scores. Total symptom scores and symptom subscores (fever, earache, irritability and feeding) did not differ significantly (P > 0.10) among children in the bacterial, bacterial/viral, viral or no pathogen groups. The subjects were divided into a bacterial and bacterial/viral group and a nonbacterial group (viral or negative). Symptom subscores did not differ between the two groups (P = 0.928). Fever scores were somewhat higher in subjects whose culture revealed S. pneumoniae (mean score, 0.62) vs. subjects with another pathogen (mean score, 0.48), but these differences were not statistically significant (P = 0.48). Physical examination scores. Fifty-seven percent of ears were described as bulging, whereas 37% were full but not bulging. A small number of ears were tapped (5%) because of redness and immobility, although they were described as neither full nor bulging. All these patients had clear signs of AOM in the contralateral ear. Ears containing fluid that cultured positive for any pathogen were more likely to be described as bulging (P = 0.001). When the subjects were divided into two groups (bacteria and bacterial/viral vs. viral and negative) and all components of the physical examination were assessed (fullness, mobility and color), no significant differences were noted (P = 0.124). However, when taken alone, a bulging TM was highly associated with isolation of bacterial pathogens or bacterial/viral combinations as compared with pure viral or negative cultures (P = 0.01). The finding of a bulging ear predicted a bacterial otitis with a positive predictive value of 74% and a negative predictive value of 45%. Bulging TMs were also noted somewhat more often in ears infected with S. pneumoniae (with or without virus, n = 27, mean score = 1.76) as compared with other bacteria (with or without virus, n = 37, mean score = 1.63, P = 0.07), viruses alone (mean score = 1.51, n = 8, P = 0.24) or no pathogen (mean score = 1.18, n = 34, P = 0.002). Mean compliance was <0.2 by tympanometry for all groups of ears. TMs tended to be described as red/yellow when any pathogen was cultured. TMs were likely to be described as shiny, dull or white when no pathogen was isolated (P < 0.04, negative culture vs. any pathogen). No consistent patterns of infection were noted when temperature (>38.3°C) or age (<24 months) was considered along with symptom or physical finding scores. Middle ear fluid volume, color and viscosity were not associated with etiologic pathogen. Discussion. A bulging ear was significantly more likely to be observed in children with bacterial or bacterial/viral AOM than in children with a pure virus infection or a totally negative culture. These results may be helpful for the clinician who is deciding whether to use antibiotics in children with suspected AOM. All ears infected with RSV, rhinovirus or adenovirus with or without bacteria had some fullness or bulging. These results contrast with earlier research that described normal TMs in ears with pure cultures of RSV.9 We found that patients infected with S. pneumoniae were somewhat more likely to present with a bulging TM and that these subjects also tended to have fever, although the comparisons did not reach a level of statistical significance. This observation is consistent with the known higher virulence of S. pneumoniae compared with that of the other bacterial pathogens infecting the middle ear such as nontypable H. influenzae and M. catarrhalis. Fullness/bulging was the most important single clinical finding associated with AOM. TM color was less important as a clinical sign in AOM, perhaps because the TM becomes erythematous when children cry during the examination. We were not able to detect differences in symptoms of children with various pathogens isolated from the middle ear fluid of infected ears. Studies from Finland have previously reported symptoms associated with AOM.10 In these studies some symptoms, although nonspecific for a particular pathogen, that were more likely to be associated with AOM included earache, rubbing of ear, night restlessness, irritability and excessive crying. Parents' opinions of the presence of earache were often correct. We also found that the combination of four key symptoms reported by parents, i.e. fever, earache (tugging), irritability and poor feeding, was an excellent measure of change over time, although still nonspecific. These four features, measured on a simple three-point scale, could be useful as diagnostic indicators of severity and quality of life in AOM clinical trials and therapeutic interventions. We recommend that the clinician obtain a careful pneumatic otoscopic assessment of the TM before prescribing antibiotic. Cerumen should be removed and TM mobility should be assessed by pneumatic otoscopy in all children. Tympanometry can provide additional, more accurate assessment of TM mobility, especially in a young child who resists pneumatic otoscopy. Temperature measurements at the time of the visit are often not helpful; many children in our practice receive antipyretics and are afebrile by the time they reach the office. Clinicians making decisions about antibiotic treatment for children with AOM need to be able to correlate symptoms with AOM severity or etiology. Most children with AOM have a concomitant illness, such as upper respiratory tract infection, bronchitis, sinusitis or pharyngitis, that may mask AOM-specific symptoms, especially in the young child who is unable to describe ear pain or hearing impairment. Therefore it may be prudent to weigh otoscopic assessment more heavily than history of symptoms when assessing a child in practice or when developing valid research instruments for classifying and grading severity of AOM. The single most important clinical feature associated with a pathogen infecting the middle ear was fullness and bulging of the TM. Erythema of the TM was a less helpful indicator. Practicing clinicians encounter numerous children with symptoms of upper respiratory infection and erythematous TMs that are not full or bulging. It is likely that many such children would do just as well without antibiotic and with symptom management alone, as long as the parent can easily contact the provider should symptoms worsen. This practice of judicious antibiotic use would limit the emergence of drug-resistant organisms in our patient population. Future efforts should be directed toward the clinical study of larger groups of children with bacterial and viral AOM, to more clearly distinguish between patients who may benefit from empiric antibiotics and patients who will recover with symptomatic management. Acknowledgments. This work was supported by National Institutes of Health Grants R01 DC 2620 and M01 RR 00073. We thank Connie Ballon-Almanza for her assistance in coordinating clinical patient care aspects of the study.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
McCormick et al. (2000) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: