Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A Voice Like the Sound of Many Waters:Inspiration, Authorial Intention, and Theological Exegesis Nicholas E. Lombardo O.P. In the book of Revelation, Jesus speaks with a voice "like the sound of many waters" (Rev 1:15).1 At least since Irenaeus, this verse has been taken to describe how God speaks to us through Scripture: with a single voice formed from the roar of a multitude.2 This understanding of Scripture, so paradigmatic for patristic and medieval exegesis, challenges us today. In academic theology, the search for what God wants to say through the text of Scripture—the search for God's own voice, and God's own intentions—has largely been abandoned. When it is not rejected as misconceived,3 it is typically set aside in favor of other hermeneutic objectives.4 And for understandable reasons: the individual human voices of Scripture, for too long, had been neglected, marginalized, and forced into boxes into which they did not fit, [End Page 825] especially when they were inconvenient to ecclesial traditions or theological systems—often precisely through tendentious appeals to God's authorship and inspiration. Yet faith in God's unity compels us to acknowledge that if God speaks through Scripture, he must speak with a single voice. Likewise, faith in God's wisdom gives us confidence that if God speaks to us, he does not speak to no purpose, and he must make it possible to know what he wants to say, at least to some extent. This article will offer an account of how God speaks through the many waters of Scripture. It will argue that God speaks through every word of Scripture, but that he speaks through those words differently from the human authors. Then it will discuss principles for discerning what God wants to say in any given passage of Scripture. Along the way, it will aim to rehabilitate a nuanced appreciation for authorial intention, both human and divine. It will also defend notions like plenary verbal inspiration and attempt to show that they can be understood in ways compatible with postcritical scholarship. If this article does not succeed in these objectives, at the very least it hopes to demonstrate that fundamental theology remains relevant for exegetical praxis, and that attempting to ground theological exegesis in sidelined topics like authorial intention, inspiration, and divine authorship need not seem stubbornly antiquated from the perspective of contemporary hermeneutics or contemporary biblical studies. It will proceed in the following way. First, drawing on Ludwig Wittgenstein's and Elizabeth Anscombe's analyses of intention, and developing Gottlob Frege's distinction between sense (Sinn) and reference (Bedeutung), it will offer some clarifications about authorial intention and its relationship to the literal sense or meaning (sensus) of Scripture.5 Second, building on these clarifications, and reflecting on the New Testament's interpretation of the Old Testament, it will draw conclusions about how God's intended meaning relates to the human authors' intended meaning.6 [End Page 826] Finally, it will discuss the implications of these conclusions for inspiration, the truth of Scripture, and theological exegesis, thus hopefully contributing to the fulfillment of Pope Benedict XVI's "fervent hope" that research on the inspiration and truth of Scripture "will progress and bear fruit both for biblical science and for the spiritual life of the faithful."7 The central thesis of this article is that, properly applied, Frege's distinction between sense and reference has great potential for solving many long-standing puzzles about inspiration, authorial intention, and theological exegesis.8 But while this central thesis is relatively straightforward, to explain what it entails and demonstrate its potential, it is necessary to touch on a number of highly contested topics. Consequently, while this article makes an attempt to engage a wide range of sources and respond to possible objections, it cannot discuss all the relevant secondary literature, nor can it adequately develop its proposals to address all of the many legitimate concerns that might be raised. Whether or not these omissions are ultimately justified, it is hoped that this article will be judged not for any individual failure in this regard, but rather for what it is: an attempt to...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Nicholas E. Lombardo (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: