This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
We are heartened to see the attention recently given to residents' overwork in Dr. David Leach's National Policy Perspective column in the December issue.1 However, bolder steps than those called for by Dr. Leach and the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) need to be taken. We propose such a step. We agree with Dr. Leach that the issue of residents' overwork is a serious one, a conclusion well supported by many studies of fatigue. A preponderance of such studies demonstrates the serious effects of fatigue on psychomotor performance, memory, and mood. One study concludes that a person who has been awake for 24 hours has a level of psychomotor functioning equivalent to that of an individual with a 0.10% blood alcohol concentration.2 Society has determined that such an individual should not be operating a vehicle, yet our profession feels that it is acceptable for him or her to be prescribing medications and performing surgery. The ACGME's approach to oversight on this problem can never be effective because the ACGME is hampered by the conflicting roles it tries to balance. First and foremost, the ACGME is responsible for maintaining the highest of educational standards, as determined by each specialty's own residency review committee. This is the role that the United States Department of Education has granted to the ACGME. However, the ACGME has recently tried to assert a presence in ensuring the quality of patient care. This is where the ACGME runs into a conflict with its other, more fundamental mission. For example, we believe that the body of literature demonstrates that reducing residents' work hours is needed to improve patient care and reduce errors in medicine. However, those in academic medicine have taken no substantive action in this area, as many feel that this could compromise residencies' educational mission and decrease the professionalism of physicians.3 Imagine yourself to be a resident who feels that your overworked state is endangering patient care. Conscientiously, you report this to the ACGME and await further action. What is the result? The residency program can be stripped of its accreditation, threatening the licensure of the residents in the program. No resident will report a violation when that could mean a loss of accreditation of the very program that trains him or her. This is one example of how the ACGME cannot ensure the quality of patient care. We do not believe that the ACGME can ever balance these two roles; one or the other will inevitably be compromised. The only solution to this problem is to vest an independent federal agency with the responsibility for ensuring that patient care standards are met. New York's work-hour standards—the Bell Regulations—are an excellent model for reform and could be applied on a nationwide scale. Residents who feel that these standards are not being observed would then have a means to address the problem without involving the ACGME. It is eminently more logical for the federal government, which funds the majority of residency programs, to ensure that these programs provide good patient care. The ACGME should constrain its activities to the mandate it was given by the federal government—ensuring that residency programs are of the highest educational quality. This separation of powers will remove the conflict that currently prevents any resolution to the problem of residents' overwork, and ensure that our values and behaviors once again work in harmony, as Dr. Leach suggests.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Srinivas et al. (2001) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: