Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Objective: To evaluate how the recent changes to the urology residency application process affect program directors' (PD) criteria for evaluating applicants. Methods: All 148 urology PDs were invited to participate in an anonymous survey administered by REDCap in 2024. Results: Forty-eight of 148 PDs (32.4%) responded to the survey. When evaluating whether to interview an applicant, the highest ranked criterion of the 9 options listed was sub-internship (sub-I) performance at the PD’s institution, followed by letters of recommendation (LORs), preference signal (PS) sent to institution, and grades on surgery clerkships. The differences between these top 4 criteria were not statistically significant. Only 23% of PDs were likely to interview applicants who did not complete a sub-I with or send a PS to their program; 23% were neutral. However, 51% of PDs were likely to interview an applicant who sent them a PS, even if the applicant did not complete any sub-Is in their geographic region or send a geographic preference signal to their region; 31% were neutral. Only 21% of PDs were likely to interview applicants who did not submit a Step 2 score with their application; 44% were neutral. Conclusions: Sub-I performance is the most important factor for urology PDs, highlighting the importance of away rotations. LOR and PS continue to have a strong influence on interview invitations, but geographic signaling and geographic location of sub-Is do not. Having a Step 2 score at the time of application has become critical for many PDs. These findings will help guide future applicants in navigating the match.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bushweller et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: