Bayesian estimates of disease maps: How important are priors?

In the fully Bayesian (FB) approach to disease mapping the choice of the hyperprior distribution of the dispersion parameter is a key issue. In this context we investigated the sensitivity of the rate ratio estimates to the choice of the hyperprior via a simulation study. We also compared the performance of the FB approach to mapping disease risk to the conventional approach of mapping maximum likelihood (ML) estimates and p-values. The study was modelled on the incidence data of insulin dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) as observed in the communes of Sardinia.