Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Aim First Responder [FR] systems are associated with improved outcomes. However, this evidence has very low certainty. We aimed to explore – using real-life data – the reality of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest [OHCA] in a Belgian municipal region where there currently is no such system.Methods We explored the hypothetical potential for an FR in all cases of OHCA attended by the physician-staffed emergency medical services [EMS] team of Ghent University Hospital [07/2020–06/2021].Results Of the 200 attended cases, 76% were residential; 54% were unwitnessed. Bystander CPR occurred in 36.5%, a public-access AED was used in only three cases. Eleven patients survived beyond hospital discharge, all but one with good neurological outcomes. In 60%, we considered an FR obsolete from start (due to irreversible death, existing advance directive, resourceful setting, early EMS arrival, OHCA not recognized, or EMS witnessed). Another 10% were traumatic OHCA, a category universally excluded. Although impossible to identify those cases from the remaining 30% (n = 60) that would truly benefit, the actual number is likely far lower due to a.o. the likelihood of prolonged no-flow in unwitnessed residential OHCA (one-third or complicating contexts, victim accessibility, or FR availability).Conclusion There might be added value for an FR system in selected populations, but the associated cost-effectiveness ratios and the potential for harm should not be ignored. Better identification of victims potentially benefitting at the system point of entry is crucial.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Voorde et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: