Key result
Cold water diving did not attenuate carotid body chemosensitivity compared to thermoneutral diving (p=0.17 for CB O2 difference between conditions).
Why the study?
Because tonic carotid body activity is reduced during exposure to cold and hyperoxia, the authors tested whether cold water diving lowers carotid body chemosensitivity and augments CO2 retention more than thermoneutral diving.
Does cold water diving compared to thermoneutral diving attenuate carotid body chemosensitivity?
Does cold water diving compared to thermoneutral diving attenuate carotid body chemosensitivity?
p-value: p=0.17
Cold water diving does not attenuate carotid body chemosensitivity compared to thermoneutral diving, suggesting it does not contribute to changes in ventilation or CO2 retention.
Does not support changes to dive protocols; leaves open temperature effects on chemosensitivity for larger studies.
Introduction: Tonic carotid body (CB) activity is reduced during exposure to cold and hyperoxia. We tested the hypotheses that cold water diving lowers CB chemosensitivity and augments CO 2 retention more than thermoneutral diving. Methods: Thirteen subjects (age: 26±4 y; BMI: 26±2 kg/m 2 ) completed two, four-hour head out water immersion protocols in a hyperbaric chamber (1.6 ATA) in cold (15°C) and thermoneutral (25°C) water. CB chemosensitivity was assessed using brief hypercapnic ventilatory response (CB CO 2 ) and hypoxic ventilatory response (CB O 2 ) tests pre-dive, 80 and 160 min into the dives (D80 and D160, respectively), immediately following and 60 min post-dive. Data are reported as an absolute mean (SD) change from pre-dive. Results: End-tidal CO 2 pressure increased during both the thermoneutral water dive (D160: +2(3) mmHg; p=0.02) and cold water dive (D160: +1(2) mmHg; p=0.03). Ventilationincreased during the cold water dive (D80: 4.13(4.38) and D160: 7.75(5.23) L·min -1 ; both p<0.01) and was greater than the thermoneutral water dive at both time points (both p<0.01). CB CO 2 was unchanged during the dive (p=0.24) and was not different between conditions (p=0.23). CB O 2 decreased during the thermonutral water dive (D80: -3.45(3.61) and D160: -2.76(4.04) L·min·mmHg -1 ; p<0.01 and p=0.03, respectively), but not the cold water dive. However, CB O 2 was not different between conditions (p=0.17). Conclusion: CB chemosensitivity was not attenuated during the cold stress diving condition and does not appear to contribute to changes in ventilation or CO 2 retention.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hess et al. (2021) studied this question. Cold water diving (15°C) vs. Thermoneutral water diving (25°C) was evaluated on Carotid body chemosensitivity (CB CO2 and CB O2) (p=0.17). Cold water diving did not attenuate carotid body chemosensitivity compared to thermoneutral diving (p=0.17 for CB O2 difference between conditions).
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: