Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Cities are epicentres of climate change, threatening the liveability, resilience and equity of urban communities, requiring rapid and, in some cases, radical grey to green (and blue) transitions. Green-blue infrastructure responds to these challenges by delivering multifunctional and strategically planned benefits from nature within cities. Yet, planning largely remains technocratic, limiting citizen agency. While participatory scenario planning is an established method to co-develop and envision resilient urban futures in cities, the extent of citizen involvement remains unclear. This paper makes two contributions, first it synthesises the evidence on how citizen insights and citizen-generated data are incorporated into green-blue infrastructure scenario planning across Europe, revealing key patterns and gaps in participation. Second it introduces the novel Citizen Scenario Cycle, a conceptual framework for analysing and strengthening citizen participation and citizen agency across the scenario planning process. Following PRISMA guidelines, a systematic identified thirty-six eligible publications from searches of academic and grey literature. Data was extracted that classified scenario characteristics, methodological approaches, participation modes and insights from citizen inclusion. The results reveal citizen participation is unevenly distributed amongst scenario stages, often concentrated to design/validation stages, and performing contributory roles, rather than substantive and sustained co-creation. Diverse and vulnerable communities were also poorly represented, as was clear evidence of policy uptake. Despite growing emphasis on participatory futures, and evidence of methodological plurality, epistemic authority to citizens is limited and the governance conditions shaping citizen influence remain poorly understood. We conclude with targeted recommendations to further respond to the challenges and gaps identified.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kirby et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: