Key result
A systematic review of 64 articles on the economic impact of endemic foot-and-mouth disease found that methods were generally poorly reported, with a median quality score of 41%.
Why the study?
Foot-and-mouth disease has large economic consequences in livestock systems, requiring robust assessment to support disease control policy.
Systematic Review (n=64)
Economic analyses of endemic foot-and-mouth disease are generally poorly reported with methodological gaps, risking inefficient resource allocation for control programs.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Diverse methods in endemic FMD economic analyses limit policy comparability; leaves open need for standardization.
Foot-and-mouth disease (FMD) has large economic consequences in livestock systems, which must be robustly assessed to support disease control policy. This study described and assessed methods used within economic analyses of FMD and its control in endemic contexts. A systematic literature search was conducted in six academic search engines. Studies were included if they applied an economic analysis to a context with endemic FMD, producing a result articulated as a monetary figure. Data collected from each article included country of study, animal population, geographical level of analysis, time horizon and type of economic analysis. Each study was scored using a quality assessment tool containing a checklist of 42 reporting criteria. Sixty-four articles were included, from 12,087 identified in the searches, describing results for 26 countries. Over half of the articles (56%) described economic impact of FMD retrospectively, often only accounting for a selection of direct costs at farm or household level. Median quality score calculated was 41% (range 8%-86%). Methods were generally poorly reported, confirming previously described difficulties in using published data to evaluate economic impact of endemic FMD. Few studies included disaggregation of public and private costs, or benefits, of FMD control, or accounted for economic or social influences of scale in vaccination programmes. Many of the studies included had gaps in both premise and methodology. If these analyses are used when planning and budgeting FMD control programmes in endemic contexts, there is a risk of inefficient resource allocation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Compston et al. (2022) conducted a systematic review in Endemic foot-and-mouth disease (n=64). Economic analysis methods was evaluated on Quality assessment score of economic analyses. A systematic review of 64 articles on the economic impact of endemic foot-and-mouth disease found that methods were generally poorly reported, with a median quality score of 41%.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: