Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The Red Army, created by the Bolsheviks in 1918, relied on knowledge transferred from the Russian Imperial Army. This knowledge travelled along different routes, including special institutions established to produce manuals and guidance for the new army, staffed by former Imperial military specialists. This article examines the fate of one such institution: the Commission for the Study and Use of the War Experience, created at the Headquarters of the Red Army by Leon Trotsky in July 1918. The Commission proved highly productive, with its works being used by historians of the First World War in Russia even today. Yet, despite its influence, the Commission was reorganized in June 1921, with all of its personnel replaced and former tsarist military specialists dismissed. This article argues that the reorganization of the Commission was not simply a result of the Bolsheviks’ hatred of former Imperial officers, but a clash between two different visions of military knowledge. It assesses these differences using a concept of ‘intellectual virtue’, usually used by historians of science and knowledge. While the tsarist military specialists saw the ‘virtuous’ military scientist as someone striving for objectivity, a powerful group of Bolsheviks in the army called for the creation of a class-driven ‘Marxist military science’ based on the experiences of the Red Army. This clash of ‘virtues’ manifested most evidently in the debate surrounding the study of the Russian Civil War. The conflict proved to be irreconcilable using the instruments of political control available to the Bolsheviks, such as political commissars and censorship; as a result, the Commission had to be rebuilt entirely.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sofya Anisimova (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: