Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
al 1 examine the use of laparoscopy and the occurrence of surgical site infection (SSI) following 5 common colectomy procedures.In this large population of Medicare beneficiaries studied from 2009 to 2013, only 46% of the colectomies were performed using a laparoscopic approach despite the technique being introduced more than 3 decades ago.This is not a new finding.Many studies have also shown fairly low adoption rates of laparoscopy in colorectal procedures.Also consistent with prior research, SSI rates were lower for laparoscopy both overall and across procedure types and comorbidity burden.After calculating a population attributable fraction, the authors found that as many as one-third of all postoperative SSIs in their sample were associated with an open surgical approach.1 These findings highlight the benefits of laparoscopy but, interestingly, the authors also found a surprising bimodal distribution for the use of laparoscopy across the 3882 hospitals studied. 1 One would assume that after 30 years, the adoption of a technique into practice would show a relatively normal distribution, if not skewed to the left.Instead, more than 25% of all hospitals performed laparoscopy less than 10% of the time for the colectomy procedures studied.This was most notable for left hemicolectomies and resections of the transverse colon where laparoscopy was infrequently used (<10% of the time) in approximately 40% of the hospitals studied.These findings highlight the ongoing struggles of adopting new techniques and procedures in the rapidly advancing field of surgery.To truly understand the extent of this problem, an understanding of the history of laparoscopy is helpful.Laparoscopy is one of the many success stories of how innovation can be rapidly disseminated in modern medicine.It was first performed in 1987 as a cholecystectomy and rapidly adopted in many procedures through the early 1990s.Within 3 years of its introduction, the use of laparoscopy for cholecystectomies had reached approximately 75%. 2 Surgeons have been slower to adopt a laparoscopic approach for other procedures, such as nephrectomies, hysterectomies, and the aforementioned colectomy.Many of the concerns for a laparoscopic approach in colectomy were rooted in operations for cancer.Early on, there were concerns that a laparoscopic approach would not be as effective and could potentially lead to an increase in cancer dissemination and recurrence.3 These concerns have been repeatedly debunked by a multitude of studies and, as of the early 2000s, common knowledge is that laparoscopic colectomy is associated not only with reduced SSI, as Caroff et al 1 have shown, but also with a reduction in postoperative pain, length of stay, readmissions, and even hospital costs.4 One potential challenge for adopting laparoscopy in colorectal surgery is the complexity of the surgery.Colorectal operations involve multiple fields, making them more difficult to learn than other single-field procedures.The learning curve is often described as "steep," but this is not quite the appropriate description for a skill that takes longer to learn.A learning curve can most simply be described as the plotted relationship between learning exposure on the x-axis and an outcome of learning on the y-axis.5 In many cases, learning exposure is defined as the number of procedures.However, the outcome examined is far more variable.Some potential learning outcomes include operative time, complications, or other important adverse outcomes of the surgery.The shape of the curve, as one might expect, is similar to an exponential distribution.In the early phases of learning, there is often rapid uptake of skills; therefore, outcomes improve at a much faster rate than later on +
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Graham et al. (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: