Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A climatology of the middle atmosphere is determined from 11-yr integrations of the U.K. Meteorological Office Unified Model and compared with 18 years of satellite observations and 5 years of data assimilation fields. The model has an upper boundary at 0.1 mb, and above 20 mb uses Rayleigh friction as a substitute for gravity wave drag. Many of the results are, however, found to be relatively insensitive to enhancing the damping above 0.3 mb. As with most general circulation models, the polar night jet in both hemispheres is too strong and does not have the observed equatorward slope with height. The model suffers from the common “cold pole” problem and, apart from a local warm pool centered just below 100 mb in northern high latitudes in January, and another at about 30 mb at 70°S in July, has a cold bias throughout the stratosphere. At the level where polar stratospheric clouds occur, the temperature bias is about −4 K in the Northern Hemisphere and up to +6 K in the Southern Hemisphere. For the majority of the southern winters, local minimum temperatures in the lower stratosphere agree well with observations but in some years the behavior is more like the Northern Hemisphere with values rising rapidly in late winter. This feature of the simulation is also seen in the South Pole temperatures at 10 mb with midwinter warmings occurring in two of the years. At 10 mb, midwinter warming behavior at the North Pole is quite well reproduced, as is the annual cycle in extratropical circulation. In the Tropics, there is no quasi-biennial oscillation, and the semiannual oscillation in the upper stratosphere has a poorly simulated westerly phase, while the easterly phase lacks the observed seasonal asymmetry. Simulated stationary wave amplitudes in the upper stratosphere lack a strong hemispheric asymmetry and are overpredicted in both hemispheres despite having roughly the correct amplitudes at 100 mb. Interannual variability in the winter stratosphere is underestimated, and again there is evidence that the model does not produce the proper hemispheric asymmetries.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Butchart et al. (1998) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: