Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In recent years, budget restrictions and low reimbursement for some laboratory tests have prompted clinical microbiologists and laboratory managers to consider outsourcing hospital microbiology and other laboratory services. Outsourcing individual, highly complex tests by community hospitals, which has always occurred, is based not only on fiscal considerations, but also on the available technical expertise and adequate test volume to maintain competence. More recently, however, movements to outsource clinical microbiology services completely or almost completely have been considered or implemented, apparently primarily on the basis of financial considerations. The removal of clinical microbiology services from the hospital setting has profound effects that extend beyond budgetary balance and have an impact on every hospital medical practice.There are some similarities, but more often differences, when considering the consequences of laboratory consolidation and the outsourcing of microbiologic testing for small, nonteaching, community hospitals compared with large medical centers and academic institutions, especially those that have responsibility for training residents and fellows. Regardless of the hospital setting, the decision should not be based solely on financial considerations and, above all, must preserve high laboratory quality for optimal patient care.In the community hospital setting, tests that are too complicated to be performed onsite, and those that are rarely ordered should be sent to a respected, reliable reference laboratory. However, standard microbiologic tests, particularly those used for the direct examination of clinical specimens for microorganisms, should not be outsourced. These tests are inexpensive and provide rapid, often critical, information to the clinician. For example, the presence of an encapsulated yeast in the cerebrospinal fluid affords the rapid diagnosis of a fungal (cryptococcal) meningitis and directs antimicrobial therapy. In the absence of this information, inappropriate empiric antibiotics would likely be given for the possibility of a bacterial pathogen. Similarly, the detection of an acid-fast bacillus in the sputum of a patient with a pulmonary infiltrate rapidly identifies a person who should be placed into respiratory isolation for the protection of health care workers.The ultimate decision as to which tests should be performed onsite must include a critical assessment of the capability of the microbiology staff. It is worse to provide an incorrect interpretation of a direct smear than to provide no interpretation at all, because the incorrect answer may inappropriately misdirect therapy. If no answer had been provided immediately, presumptive broad-spectrum therapy may have been continued until a result was returned. We should note, however, that direct examinations are so important for good medical care in any clinical setting that the appropriate response may be to upgrade the capability of the laboratory staff (more training, better salary to attract more qualified applicants, etc), rather than to delay unduly the provision of a timely initial result.All but the smallest, most limited laboratories should consider retaining routine cultures for bacteria and common yeast. One option is to inoculate plates and refer the identification of more difficult organisms, such as anaerobic bacteria and molds, to a suitable reference laboratory. Cultures for bacteria and fungi aid in the rapid detection of the etiologic agents of most hospital-associated infections. The methods for the cultivation and identification of most bacteria and fungi are not expensive, with adherence to cost-effective microbiologic methods. Expenses, however, will rapidly accrue if excessive, unnecessary testing is permitted.Although perhaps not immediately apparent, retaining clinical microbiology services may actually be cost-effective for the hospital. The rapid and accurate identification of microbial pathogens affords directed therapy, thereby decreasing the use of broad-spectrum antimicrobial therapy, and diminishes the length of hospital stay and unnecessary ancillary procedures, such as additional radiologic studies.12 These savings, which may not be observed directly by the laboratory manager, are seen at the hospital administrator level. The earlier discharge of patients, the ordering of fewer unnecessary ancillary tests, and the more directed use of antimicrobial therapy, which decreases selective pressures important for the emergence of drug-resistant pathogens, result in cost savings that are not easy to identify. If these savings are tallied, however, the benefit to the whole organization is likely to be substantial. Such cost savings, which are based on rapid testing and reporting, may not be possible if onsite testing is eliminated and specimens are forwarded to a reference laboratory.In addition to providing cost-effective, high-quality testing of patient specimens, clinical microbiology laboratories in sophisticated hospitals and academic medical centers have the additional responsibilities of teaching and research. The programs should foster and support research and scholarly activity as well as train the next generation of health care professionals. Onsite microbiology services are considered so important by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education that this council has mandated that modern facilities be available and functioning at the primary training site, not only for residents of pathology and laboratory medicine, but also for internal medicine fellows pursuing subspecialty training in infectious diseases. Failure to comply with these requirements may result in the loss of accreditation by the Residency Review Committee of the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education, with subsequent loss of funding. A related issue that deserves consideration is the removal of microbiology and other laboratory services to a distant location, although still within the organization. For small, nonteaching hospitals in which direct consultation between the microbiologist and clinicians is infrequent an offsite laboratory may be acceptable, but only if arrangements for the prompt transport of specimens and reporting of results are adequate. For larger institutions and particularly for hospitals that support residency and fellowship programs, an offsite location of the hospital laboratory may cause major disruptions in communication and prevent the accomplishment of the educational mission. In addition, administrators should look carefully at the putative savings once they have factored in adequate transportation, which may entail more than a single car and driver, and must make provisions for emergency transport. The cost of duplicate equipment and personnel required for onsite stat testing or inoculation of media must also be entered into the equation. Certain microorganisms, such as Shigella spp and respiratory syncytial virus, do not survive transportation well, regardless of the precautions taken. The costs associated with testing the quality of the transportation methods should also be considered, because regulatory agencies, such as the Clinical Laboratories Improvement Act agencies and the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations, place the responsibility of ensuring the integrity of the send-out specimen on the sending laboratory. Finally, the anthrax bioterrorism event of the past year demonstrates that the microbiology laboratory of any community hospital may become the “frontline” laboratory. The local laboratory will probably not process environmental or forensic specimens, but clinical specimens will be evaluated there initially—with or without prior suspicion of bioterrorism. Poorer outcomes and perhaps adverse epidemiologic sequelae should be expected from such events if laboratories are not staffed with competent personnel who interact with clinicians and have the basic skills required to assess an agent as a potential biologic threat, even if definitive testing is performed elsewhere.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Procop et al. (2003) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: