Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
R esearch on the correlates and causes of government growth has constituted something of a cottage industry in recent years (cf. reviews by Lybeck 1988; Larkey, Stolp, and Winer 1981; Borcherding 1977; and Tarschys 1975). Research has focused on the empirical utility of factors that have been proposed as potential sources of government growth (e.g., Berry and Lowery 1987; Cameron 1978). Research also has focused on methodological debates about how to measure and compare the scope of the public sector over time and cross-nationally (e.g., Klein 1985; Lewis-Beck and Rice 1985; Beck 1976). This paper, however, is not primarily concerned with the question of what factor (or factors) best explains government growth; nor is it primarily concerned with methodological issues. Instead, it seeks to show that the selection of explanatory variables as well as questions of methodology must turn on substantive decisions about what is to be explained. My argument is that focusing on the size of government in the aggregate (however measured) tends to mask the issue of what aspects of the government's responsibilities are increasing or decreasing in size and importance. This is consistent with Rose's injunction that we must consider what government does as well as why it grows. (1984: 1). On his view, size is only one issue, and not necessarily the most important one: To measure the totality of government by one undifferentiated observation reduces everything to a denominator so common that it tells us nothing in particular (1984: 5). Rose proposes a programmatic approach as a way of analyzing the mix of qualitatively different activities in which governments can be engaged. Such a focus permits a wider and richer range of comparisons than a focus only on aggregate measure of government size. The activities on which governments expend resources can vary significantly. Two different governments may differ in size because
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kenneth N. Bickers (1991) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: