Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The article by Post and Whitehouse1 on ethics and antidementia drugs in this issue of the Journal is a welcome addition to the literature for several reasons. First, the face validity of the difficult issues raised by Post and Whitehouse will be obvious to clinicians. The vignettes in the paper will resonate for thoughtful physicians who struggle to communicate the potential benefits and burdens of therapies to patients and families and then decide with them whether to start or stop antidementia drugs. Second, this is one of a relatively small number of articles that draws our attention to the ethical dilemmas encountered by patients, families, and care providers throughout the course of a dementing illness. At times it seems as if those interested in ethics believe that the only points worthy of analysis in dementia are those regarding the disclosure of the diagnosis and the end of life.2, 3 Third, Post and Whitehouse remind us that even in an era of practice guidelines, critical pathways, and other efforts to manage care, important decisions remain to be made together by patients, families, and physicians. Medical decisionmaking, especially in the case of antidementia drugs, remains highly and appropriately dependent on the values, preferences, and goals of care held by the parties involved in the decisions. I believe that the paper by Post and Whitehouse is most important, however, because it has touched the tip of a very important iceberg. Although the authors do an admirable job of discussing antidementia drugs, lurking beneath the surface is the much bigger problem of identifying and addressing the root causes of why it is so difficult to make decisions about specific treatments or procedures for patients with dementia, whether these are antidementia drugs, feeding tubes, CPR, or even flu shots and mammograms. As I have written with respect to preventive medicine decisions and dementia,4 I believe these individual treatment decisions are difficult, in large part, because of a failure to articulate and discuss explicitly the goals of care for patients with dementia. On a fundamental level, one could restate this in Aristotelian terms as a failure to articulate a shared vision of “the good life” for someone suffering from a progressive and irreversible dementia (B. Jennings, Feb. 3, 1998, personal communication). On a practical level, if we are not sure just what it is we are aiming at or trying to accomplish for a patient with dementia, then it makes sense for it to be difficult to decide whether to use a particular medication or technology. In the absence of explicit goals of care, how do we currently decide how to care for patients with dementia? The default approach seems to be identifying medical problems and attempting to solve, or at least address, each one of them. This approach goes something like this: if the blood sugar or pressure are high, lower them with medications; if chest pain occurs, evaluate and treat for coronary artery disease; if renal failure develops, institute dialysis; and so on. At some point for patients with dementia, this approach breaks down. Either families or physicians begin to feel that some interventions are no longer appropriate. This may be because of problems with compliance or the sense that particular tests or treatments are too burdensome for an uncomprehending patient. At such a point, some technologies may be dropped, but there may still not be a coherent care plan aiming at specific goals. Often the other extreme to the “fix everything” approach takes over, and patients with dementia are considered inappropriate candidates for most kinds of treatment regardless of the values, goals, and preferences of the patient and family. This approach can verge on nihilism and runs the risk of leaving patients and families with a sense of abandonment. See also p 784 How, then, should we be setting goals for the care of patients with dementia? First, we need to discuss with patients and families what we can do for people affected by dementia. Some of the goals of care and examples of corresponding activities that might be pursued as part of a care plan are outlined in Table 1. Second, we need to recognize and discuss the extent to which each of these goals will be pursued and how this may change over time during the course of a dementia. Most of our patients receive care that is a blend, to varying degrees and at varying times, of prevention, cure, rehabilitation, palliation, and family support. The extent to which each goal is pursued should be a function primarily of the preferences of patients and families, as influenced by such factors as the stage of the dementia, comorbid conditions, severity of symptoms, and the potential benefits and burdens of any proposed course of action. For example, a woman in the earliest stages of Alzheimer's disease with few other medical problems and the goals of palliating and slowing her dementia, preventing other illnesses, and prolonging life might end up taking donepezil and vitamin E, receiving vaccinations for pneumonia and influenza, and opting for hospitalization and even ICU care and ventilatory support in the event of a severe pneumonia. Most of her care plan would look essentially the same as that of a patient without dementia. At the other extreme, a patient with severe dementia who is residing in a nursing home and no longer able to recognize family might have care focusing exclusively on palliation of both psychiatric symptoms and symptoms caused by other medical illnesses. This patient's care plan might resemble a hospice care plan, even without formal enrollment in hospice. In between the two extremes represented by the cases above, the goals of care and the care plan should be negotiated by the patient (if possible), the family, and the physician. Of course, the reality of negotiating the goals of care and a corresponding care plan for all patients is not as straight-forward in practice as I have described it above. The goals of care seen in Table 1 are not rigid, mutually exclusive categories; pursuing multiple goals at any point in time is the norm, and some treatments may simultaneously promote one goal while frustrating another. Disagreements may exist between families and physicians or among family members. Above all, these discussions take considerable time, something that is at a premium in practices today. Once the goals of care have been agreed on, however, it does become easier to evaluate specific treatments because one can think about the extent to which a particular therapy or course of action helps everyone move toward those goals of care. Geriatricians are probably most familiar with thinking about goal-setting and care-planning within the context of providing hospice care to dying patients. In hospice, the explicit goals of care include palliation of symptoms and support of family. When I work with medical students or residents who are not very familiar with hospice, I ask them to scrutinize each proposed intervention and ask, “Does this make the patient more comfortable? Will this help the patient and family cope better?” Many proposed interventions, such as blood tests, medications for osteoporosis, and cholesterol-lowering agents, are discarded once they are filtered in this fashion. Formal enrollment in a hospice program makes the goals of care more explicit and the care plan more rational. Another type of medical care familiar to geriatricians that focuses on explicit goals of care is rehabilitation medicine. In rehabilitation medicine, one aims at improving a patient's function in one or more domains, often in response to an injury, illness, or other event. A rehabilitation care plan, in either the inpatient or outpatient setting, details very specific goals, and progress notes are keyed to how the patient is doing in relation to attaining these goals. Reimbursement is linked to demonstrating continued progress toward the goals of care. Geriatricians are uniquely situated to serve as advocates for patients with dementia, insisting on explicit goals of care and rational care plans. Not only are geriatricians familiar with goal-setting from their exposure to hospice and rehabilitation medicine, we are comfortable caring for both the patient's dementia and his or her other medical problems. In addition, we are used to providing comprehensive care to patients with dementia throughout the course of the illness and across care sites, from diagnosis to death and from home to hospital to nursing home. Geriatricians should take the lead in demonstrating that setting goals and constructing corresponding care plans can improve both the decisionmaking process and the quality of care for patients with dementia. Another role for geriatricians emerges once one extends the examination of these issues from the level of patients, families, and physicians to the level of the healthcare system. Medicare is oriented to acute medicine and so-called skilled care needs. The traditional “fix everything” approach described above is reinforced by a system that (1) pays readily for the ICU stay of any dementia patient who rolls into a hospital emergency room with multi-organ failure; (2) makes rehabilitation services most easily obtainable and reimbursed when they are for acute injuries or events; and (3) limits hospice care to the final 6 months of life by policy (and the final 36 days of life, on average, in practice5). On the other hand, most illnesses, including dementia, are chronic in nature, with acute exacerbations, intercurrent illnesses, and progression of underlying disease all contributing to clinical deterioration. Patients with dementia need preventive care, maintenance therapies, and palliative care over many years, and their families need support and other social services. Thus, it is appropriate for geriatricians and the AGS to advocate for changes in the healthcare system that would lead to a better matching of services with the goals of care for patients with dementia.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Greg A. Sachs (1998) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: