Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Clostridium species (phylum Firmicutes) are gram-positive endospore-forming anaerobic bacteria that inhabit diverse environments including animal and human gut, sewage, lake sediments, and paddy soil. Previously, several growth-enhancing Clostridium species isolated from the root and rhizosphere of rice seedlings were classified as plant growth-promoting rhizobacteria (PGPR; Febri et al., 2014; Zeiller et al., 2015); however, some caused disease in potato and kiwifruit (Shabuer et al., 2015; Spigaglia et al., 2020). In agriculture, anaerobic soil disinfestation (ASD), a preplanting soil treatment method that creates anaerobic soil conditions, was conventionally utilized to suppress the growth of soil-borne pathogens such as Ralstonia solanacearum, Fusarium oxysporum, and Verticillium spp. (Momma, 2008; Shennan et al., 2009; Ueki et al., 2018). The determinants of ASD were mainly reported as short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs), such as acetic acid and butyric acid (BA), derived from the metabolic pathways of anaerobic bacteria such as Clostridium spp. (Swilling et al., 2021). However, whether Clostridium spp. closely interact with the plant root under anaerobic conditions remains unclear. Furthermore, little information is available on how the belowground plant–Clostridium interaction contributes to aboveground plant fitness traits such as immunity. In this study, we established a new protocol to isolate anaerobic bacteria from three root compartments, rhizosphere (soil surrounding the root), rhizoplane (root surface), and endosphere (root interior; Ueki et al., 2007; Edwards et al., 2015), in paddy soil, which is an ideal ecological niche for anaerobic bacteria (Liesack et al., 2000). Then, the ability of Clostridium spp. to colonize plant root and improve plant fitness by activating induced systemic resistance (ISR) was evaluated. Lastly, we identified bacterial metabolites that function as ISR determinants, and demonstrated the potential application of BA as a bioprotectant. Collectively, we show that Clostridium spp. elicit ISR and improve plant fitness through root colonization. We compared the microbiome composition of three rice root compartments, rhizosphere, rhizoplane, and endosphere, with that of bulk (unplanted) soil sampled from five different locations in South Korea: Suwon (SW), Cheongju (CJ), Chuncheon (CC), Daegu (DG), and Iksan (IS). A total of 2485 828 sequence reads were generated by 16S rRNA sequencing, with an average of 30 646 reads per sample. The β-diversity indices determined by principal coordinate analysis (PCoA) showed that the microbiome composition of bulk soil was distinct from that of the endosphere and different from those of the rhizospheres and rhizoplane at five sites. Interestingly, the microbiota of rhizosphere and rhizoplane samples were similar in Suwon (SW), Cheongju (CJ), Chuncheon (CC), and Iksan (IS; Fig. 1a). The PCoA results indicated that rhizosphere and rhizoplane samples shared similar microbiota, whereas bulk soil and endosphere had different microbiota. A permutational ANOVA (PERMANOVA; Adonis) analysis showed that the microbiota in each rhizocompartment clustered significantly at all five sites (P = 0.001, for all five sites: SW, CJ, CC, DG, and IS in South Korea). PCoA analysis for the five regions together revealed that the microbiota was clustered by each region rather than by rhizocompartments (Supporting Information Fig. S1). In addition, α-diversity analysis indicates that microbial diversity was highest in bulk soil and rhizosphere, and lowest in endosphere at all five sites (Fig. 1b), indicating that the endosphere is composed of specific microbiota selectively recruited from the bulk soil and rhizosphere (Hardoim et al., 2008; Rodríguez et al., 2020). Analysis of relative abundance at the phylum level revealed that Firmicutes, Proteobacteria, Chloroflexi, Actinobacteria, and Patescibacteria were dominant at all sites (Fig. 1c). The total relative abundance of Firmicutes was up to 62% in the rhizosphere and rhizoplane. Among all three rhizocompartments, rhizosphere showed the highest abundance of Firmicutes at all sites except DG and endosphere showed the lowest abundance of Firmicutes at all sites except SW. Notably, Clostridium was the most dominant Firmicutes genus in the rhizosphere, with a relative abundance of up to 91% (Fig. 1d). Specifically, at the CJ, DG, SW, CC, and IS sites, the abundance of Clostridium spp. was 89%, 73%, 91%, 88%, and 90%, respectively, in the rhizosphere, and 84%, 45%, 63%, 72%, and 77%, respectively, in bulk soil (Fig. 1d). The relative abundance ratio of Clostridium in Firmicutes was significantly higher in the rhizosphere than in bulk soil at all sites. Based on these results, we examined the percentage of reads belonging to Clostridium spp. in each rhizocompartment (Fig. S2a). Interestingly, the percentage of Clostridium read counts followed the order rhizosphere > rhizoplane > endosphere at all sites. The percentages of Clostridium spp. in three rhizocompartments in CC were higher than at other sites and were similar to each other. These results indicate that the environment of the rhizosphere is the most conducive for the survival of Clostridium, whereas that of the endosphere is the most challenging (Fig. S2a). Plant root is known as a gatekeeper that differentiates the bacteria found in rhizosphere and endosphere from those found in bulk soil (Liu et al., 2017). Therefore, we hypothesized that differences in Clostridium ratios between different rhizocompartments could be attributed to differences in oxygen gradient distribution caused by physical barriers, such as the plant root epidermis and endodermis. In addition, oxygen from the atmosphere is transported to the rice root through the aerenchymatous tissue and released into the soil as radial oxygen loss (ROL; Armstrong, 1971). The oxygen introduced into the soil from the root creates an oxygen gradient for each rhizocompartment (Maisch et al., 2019). Compared with the atmosphere, oxygen concentration was 40–60% within the root and 20% on the root surface. Previously, in the rhizosphere of 3-wk-old rice seedlings, at 8 cm below the ground, the oxygen-rich region expanded to 0.4 mm around the root (Revsbech et al., 1999). Based on these results, we hypothesized that the oxygen gradient between the endosphere and bulk soil plays a key role in the distribution of microbiota. To understand the role of oxygen in root microbiome composition (Song et al., 2021), we compared differences in the operational taxonomic units (OTUs) of aerobic and anaerobic bacteria among bulk soil, rhizosphere, rhizoplane, and endosphere. First, we selected OTUs defined as Clostridium (Figs 1e, S2b–e). At CJ and SW, sequences belonging to OTUs 219, 224, 258, 93, 119, and 139 were most abundant in the rhizosphere, followed by rhizoplane and endosphere (Fig. 1e). These results are consistent with the relative abundance and percent of Clostridium present in total read counts, indicating that Clostridium species were enriched in the rhizosphere and were less frequent in the endosphere and bulk soil (Figs 1e, S2a–e). The low abundance of clostridia in bulk soil was presumed to be caused by the lower nutrient availability in soil than in the rhizosphere and rhizoplane, as well as by the lower oxygen level. Interestingly, the aerobic bacteria read counts classified as Bradyrhizobium and Sphingomonas (Surpin & Maier, 1998; Kopejtka et al., 2021) were high in the endosphere, and less high in the rhizosphere (Figs 1f, S3a–c). Subsequently, OTUs of representative aerobic Bacillus spp. were rarely detected at the five sites (Fig. S3d–f). Our results are in agreement with those of a previous study reporting a negative correlation between the relative abundance of Clostridium and that of Bacillus (Hewavitharana et al., 2021). Overall, our results suggest that oxygen is one of the key factors that determines the prevalence of Clostridium in each rhizocompartment. Although Clostridium is known as a representative genus of anaerobic bacteria, its OTUs were also detected in the rice root endosphere, which is rich in oxygen (Maisch et al., 2019). To explain how anaerobic bacteria thrive in an oxygen-rich environment, it was proposed that Clostridium spp. form spores, which can tolerate oxygen (Shen et al., 2019). However, this theory could not be proven because it was difficult to extract DNA from bacterial endospore using the standard protocol for metagenome analysis (Belgrader et al., 1999). Another theory is that specific metabolites produced by Clostridium spp., such as aromatic polyketides, allow bacterial vegetative cells to be active even in an oxygen-rich plant environment (Shabuer et al., 2015). In addition, the composition of the soil microbiome is affected by the gradients of nutrient and defense components released from the plant (Pascale et al., 2020; Kashyap et al., 2021; Kawa & Brady, 2022). Taken together, these results support the possibility of interactions between Clostridium and the host plant at the rhizocompartments. To examine the interaction between Clostridium and rice plants, 89 bacterial strains including 18 strains of Clostridium were isolated from each rhizocompartment as described previously (Ueki et al., 2007; Edwards et al., 2015; Browne et al., 2016), with slight modifications (see the Materials and Methods section; Notes S1; Fig. S4). First, we investigated rice root colonization by C. butyricum strain CC2 as an indicator of the interaction with plant root (Lugtenberg & Kamilova, 2009) because a strong interaction of this strain with plant species has rarely been reported. Fluorescence in situ hybridization analysis revealed that the intensity of light signal gradually increased in the epidermis cell junction of rice root from 3 to 7 d post-inoculation (dpi; Fig. S5; Video S1). Azospirillum brasilense Sp6 known as root colonization bacteria, used as a positive control, randomly colonized the area of the rice root surface (rhizoplane), especially hairy root. By contrast, no bacterial cells of Escherichia coli BW25113 were detected (Fig. S5). Thus, we demonstrate, for the first time, that C. butyricum CC2 can colonize the rice root surface, which is an oxygen-enriched zone. To explore the effects of Clostridium species on plant physiology, we evaluated the ability of 18 Clostridium isolates to activate ISR in rice seedlings (Table S1). CC2, DG7, DG10, and DG12 were identified as ISR-positive strains, while IS21, IS13, CC3, and CJ17 were identified as ISR-negative strains. All the four ISR-positive strains significantly decreased the length of lesions caused by the rice bacterial blight pathogen, Xanthomonas oryzae pv oryzae (Xoo), by 52–72% compared with the control (Fig. 2a,b). This reduction in lesion length was similar to that caused by 0.05 mM benzothiadiazole treatment (positive control). Subsequently, under glasshouse conditions, lesion length was significantly reduced (41.1%) by CC2 treatment compared with the control (Figs 2c, S6a). Many ISR determinants produced by rhizobacteria have been reported previously include the cell membrane-localized exopolysaccharides and lipopolysaccharides as well as the secreted metabolites such as siderophores, salicylic acid, bacterial volatiles, and cyclic lipopeptides (Ryu et al., 2004; Nadarajah, 2016). Treatment with extracellular supernatant diluted 10-fold significantly decreased the lesion length by 85.3% compared with the control (Figs 2d, S6b). To identify specific ISR-related compounds in the supernatant of bacterial culture, we evaluated bacterial metabolites between ISR-positive and -negative strains (Fig. 2a) by liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry (LC–MS; Tyc et al., 2017). However, the LC–MS data showed no differences in metabolites between the two groups of strains (Fig. S6c). Previously, organic SCFAs and volatile compounds were identified as the major metabolites of Clostridium spp. (Vees et al., 2020). Therefore, we performed gas chromatography–mass spectrometry (GC–MS) analysis of the extracellular supernatant containing bacterial metabolites. Butyric acid was detected only in the supernatant of ISR-positive bacteria, C. butyricum CC2, C. guangxiense DG7, C. diolis DG10, and C. nigeriense DG12, but not in that of ISR-negative bacteria (Figs 2e, S6d). In addition, a strong correlation was detected between BA content and ISR capacity (P = 0.0357, R2 = 0.548; Fig. 2f). Next, we determined the minimum concentration of BA required for activating ISR. Application of 100 nM and 10 μM BA to rice root resulted in the greatest resistance to Xoo (Figs 2g, S7a). Notably, both 22:00 h and 1 mM BA showed similar biological activity, which was unusual. Further evaluation revealed no ISR at concentrations below 100 fM (Fig. S7b,c). These results indicate that 22:00 h BA is the minimum concentration required to elicit ISR. 100 nM and 10 μM BA were the most effective concentrations against Xoo (Fig. 2g). In addition, while 100 nM BA was undetectable due to the detection limit of GC–MS, it elicited ISR in rice (Figs S8, 2g). When we tested whether BA with volatile properties directly affects the growth of Xoo inoculated into leaves, we found that treatment with BA at concentrations ranging from 13:00 h to 1 mM did not inhibit the growth of Xoo (Fig. S9a). In 100 nM and 10 μM BA treatments, the expression of Pathogenesis-related 1b (PR1b) increased by 1.34- and 1.83-fold, respectively, at 12 h post-inoculation (hpi) compared with the control (Fig. 2h), indicating the activation of defense priming. Next, we asked whether strain CC2 could produce BA under in situ conditions (paddy soil). Unlike our expectation, the detectable amount of BA decreased with time, and the minimum amount was detected on day 7 (Fig. S9b). However, an additional analysis revealed that 100 nM BA could not be detected by GC–MS (Fig. S8). Our result suggests that BA-elicited ISR can occur even below the GC–MS detection limit when BA is produced by Clostridium in soil (Figs 2g, S8). Altogether, these results suggest that BA produced by C. butyricum strain CC2 is critical for triggering ISR. Because BA produced by Clostridium could not be detected in soil, we used an indirect approach to evaluate in situ BA biosynthesis in response to rice root exudates by examining the expression of bacterial BA biosynthesis-related genes, butyrate kinase (buk) and phosphotransbutyrase (ptb; Fig. 2i,j). BA is synthesized from glucose via the BUK pathway, in which PTB phosphorylates butyryl-CoA to form butyryl phosphate, which is then converted to butyrate by BUK, the final enzyme in this pathway. At 30 min after treatment with the root exudates of 7- and 14-d-old rice seedlings, the expression of buk increased by 1.4-and 1.53-fold, respectively (Fig. 2i), whereas that of ptb increased by 1.48- and 1.33-fold, respectively (Fig. 2j). Root exudates contain many organic substances including sugars, which are also essential for recruiting rhizobacteria (Bais et al., 2006). Therefore, these results suggest that CC2 can produce BA and trigger ISR by interacting with rice roots. Collectively, we demonstrate that Clostridium spp. (mostly obligate anaerobes) function as PGPR, and that Clostridium spp. produce BA. Additional interesting questions remain: how do Clostridium spp. interact with other anaerobic and aerobic bacteria in soil?; what is the direct effect of BA on rice soil microbiome?; and what other bacterial determinants, if any, activate plant immunity under anaerobic conditions?. Further studies are needed to investigate the effects of Clostridium spp. on upland crops such as wheat, pepper, and tomato. Given their critical advantage, such as ability to maintain stable spore formation under aerobic conditions, allowing their preparation before their application in fields, Clostridium spp. could have potential as a biofertilizer and bioprotective agent that only germinates under anaerobic conditions, such as the rice rhizosphere. The National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) funded by the Ministry of Science and ICT (NRF-2021M3A9I5021439); Cooperative Research Program for Agriculture Science and Technology Development (Project no. PJ016990022023) of Rural Development Administration; Strategic Initiative for Microbiomes in Agriculture and Food, Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs, S. Korea (as part of the multi-ministerial Genome Technology to Business Translation Program 918017-4) and KRIBB Initiative Program, South Korea. None declared. CMR designed the study; S-HJ, MR, SL and J-SJ performed the experiments; S-HJ and J-SK analyzed the data; S-HJ and C-MR wrote the manuscript. The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. Fig. S1 Total principal coordinate analysis of rhizocompartments at five sites. Fig. S2 Clostridium spp. enriched in the rhizosphere of rice. Fig. S3 Aerobic bacteria enriched in the endosphere of rice. Fig. S4 Isolation of 18 Clostridium species from rice rhizocompartments. Fig. S5 Root colonization of Clostridium butyricum CC2. Fig. S6 Supernatant analysis of induced systemic resistance-positive and -negative strains by liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry and gas chromatography–mass spectrometry. Fig. S7 Butyric acid elicits induced systemic resistance against X. oryzae pv oryzae in rice. Fig. S8 Evaluation of detection limit of butyric acid using gas chromatography–mass spectrometry-headspace solid phase microextraction. Fig. S9 Direct and indirect effects of butyric acid on growth of Xoo. Notes S1 Details of the methods. Table S1 List of Clostridium species isolated from the different rhizocompartments of rice. Table S2 PCR primers used in this paper. Video S1 Colonization of Clostridium butyricum CC2 on the rice root surface. Please note: Wiley is not responsible for the content or functionality of any Supporting Information supplied by the authors. Any queries (other than missing material) should be directed to the New Phytologist Central Office. Please note: The publisher is not responsible for the content or functionality of any supporting information supplied by the authors. Any queries (other than missing content) should be directed to the corresponding author for the article.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jung et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: