Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This special issue of the CDJ asks ‘whither community development in an era of ‘climate emergency'?’. Naturally, posing this question invites a panoply of further questions: What do we mean by community development? What role, however modest, can community work really play in addressing the ‘climate emergency’, and how is the nature of community work altered by it? What does addressing the ‘climate emergency’ means for working-class, poor and racialized communities? What does it mean for the gendered division of labour within these communities? What role can communities most affected by, and dependent on, industries that exacerbate ‘climate emergency’ play in the wider movement for climate action? These are some of the urgent questions addressed by our contributors in the form of articles, interviews and activist reflections. To address crucial questions such as these, a good way to proceed is by interrogating the implicit problem representation in the discursive construction of ‘climate emergency’. Our use of scare quotes does not signify a right-wing populist (or postmodernist) dismissal of the truth of climate and environmental science, whether grounded in the ‘obscurantist denial’ or ‘underestimation’ of scientific authority (de Sousa 2021, p. 151). Rather, our intention is to foreground the fact that the dominant problem representation of ‘climate emergency’ is partially an issue of discursive hegemony, whereby the educated and predominantly white middle-class, often located in the Global North, have more access to shape the dominant discourse on the environment – in abstract terms, artificially divorced from direct experience or other problems, such as parts-per-million particulate matter or greenhouse gas emissions (Hulme, 2019). That there is an objective emergency is, in an important sense, beyond dispute. As most readers are aware, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change report presented forceful and alarming evidence that our current climatic trajectory means urban water scarcity, inland and coastal flooding, extreme precipitation, landslides and heat stress (IPCC, 2018, 2021), the latter report being called ‘Code Red for Humanity’ by the UN General Secretary. Yet, any dominant problem representation and its attendant presuppositions and closures has very real material consequences whose positive and negative dimensions are disproportionately distributed – according to various axes of inequality – among different communities through policy, planning and action (Bacchi, 1999). Indeed, for some sections of humanity, ‘Code Red’ passed a long time ago, whereas others are protected by privilege from its full force. For this reason, we begin this special issue by unpacking, rather than assuming, the politics of ‘climate emergency’. We not only ask what is the promise of the global climate declarations movement for community development but also ask what are its aporias and contradictions?
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
McGregor et al. (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: