Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Shell-tempered ceramics first appear in the archaeological record of the upper Mississippi River Valley in the postHopewellian period (ca. A.D. 250-500) of the Woodland Tradition as a minority ware in northwestern Illinois and south-central Wisconsin. Following a five-century hiatus, shell tempering was reintroduced via Middle Mississippian expansion from the American Bottom into the northern hinterland about A.D. 1000-1050. The following century witnessed the adoption of this technology by Terminal Woodland groups as they also incorporated corn agriculture into their economy. After A.D. 1150, shell tempering dominated the ceramics of the intensive agricultural Oneota Culture until French contact and the coinciding introduction of brass kettles. Experimental replication of Oneota wares, coupled with archaeological evidence, offers insight into the manufacturing technology of this last prehistoric culture in this region. Introduction One of the defining characteristics of the late prehistoric Oneota Culture in the upper Midwest is a globular-shaped ceramic vessel that is tempered with crushed shell (Keyes 1927). It has long been assumed that Oneota pottery developed from the introduction of shell-tempered pottery as a result of interaction between the Middle Mississippian complexes in the American Bottom (e.g., Cahokia) and local Woodland peoples to the north about A.D. 1000 (Griffin 1960). However, a long-running debate concerning the origins of Oneota includes challenges to this evolutionary scenario. Some have interpreted a few early radiocarbon dates as showing that Oneota emerged prior to Middle Mississippian contact (Gibbon 1969, 1972; Hall 1962; Hurley 1975; Overstreet 1976, 1989, 1995, 1997, 1998, 2000, 2001; Overstreet and Richards 1992; Richards et al. 1998). Others favor a Late Woodland to Oneota transition inspired by Middle Mississippian interaction, and this view appears to be strengthened as more radiocarbon dates become available for Emergent Oneota components (Benchley et al. 1997; Boszhardt 1998, 2004a, 2004b; Boszhardt et al. 1995; Brown and Asch 1990; Stoltman 1983; Tiffany 1988). Complicating the issue are documented examples of shell-tempered vessels in the upper Mississippi River Valley that clearly predate Oneota by several centuries (Hall 2004). This paper seeks to review evidence for pre-Oneota shell tempering in the upper Mississippi Valley, how this factors in to questions regarding the emergence of Oneota, and why shell tempering replaced grit-tempered Woodland wares throughout much of the region. The Upper Mississippi River Valley The upper Mississippi River drainage encompasses a huge region of the upper Midwest, with tributaries extending from near Lake Michigan to the Missouri River and from the Mississippi's source at Lake Itasca in north-central Minnesota to the imposing natural barrier at the Rock Island Rapids (Figure 1). This region is crossed by the northern edge of the prairie peninsula and originally included short- to high-grass prairie in the west, prairie/savannah across the middle, and deciduous forest to the northeast (Curtis 1959). The many fresh water rivers and lakes in this region provided habitat for a variety of fresh water mussels, with major beds along the Mississippi River at Prairie du Chien and Rock Island (Theler 1987). Clay sources exist throughout the region in floodplains, as glacial outwash deposits within the Mississippi Valley Trench, on ancient bluff tops of the unglaciated Driftless Area in southwestern Wisconsin, and within glacial deposits to the east and west. Early Chronology of Shell Tempering Late Middle and Early Late Woodland The earliest known shell-tempered pottery in this region occurs in central and southern Wisconsin and at the Albany Mounds village site (11 WtI) in northwestern Illinois. In central and southeastern Wisconsin, Baraboo ware (including plain and net marked varieties) has been found in stratigraphie contexts, always as minority types. …
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Robert F. Boszhardt (2008) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: