Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Through the human eye, urbanization has been perceived as a proxy of progress and prosperity. Yet, such perception could be misleading when urbanization processes are primarily driven by socio-economic and political forces, often overlooking the ecological sphere in which they develop. Thus, the resulting cities commonly lack the proper multivariate planning and management strategies required to tackle the complex issues related to such dynamic systems. Examples of the later are ubiquitous across the globe, with some of the largest supercities representing the epitome of unbalanced systems, where social inequality peeks (United Nations 2015). Although urbanization has improved some aspects of human health due to the presence of health care and sanitary systems—making them less hazardous when contrasted with some wildlands and agricultural systems–, there are many other facets (e.g. social inequality, heterogeneous urban development) that have been overlooked under recurrent reductionist visions (United Nations 2015; Hassell et al. 2017). Studies have provided evidence of the diverse roles that urbanization can play from the human health perspective. It is important to underline that most human pathogens derive from wild zoonotic sources, and the urbanization process, along with its impacts on the surrounding landscape, provide novel opportunities for pathogens swapping among hosts that otherwise would be highly unlikely to happen in non-urban habitats (Jones et al. 2008; Gottdenker et al. 2014). Among urban systems, large cities surrounded by agricultural land-uses, particularly in tropical regions with higher mammal diversity, have higher probabilities for human emergent infectious diseases (Allen et al. 2017). Although urbanization has been regarded as a ‘magic wand’ to solve infectious diseases and associated complications, such perception directly depends on the quality of the sanitation system in place, along with other urban components, such as security, food source supply and land tenure security, among others (e.g. Levy et al. 2014). Under scenarios where social security systems fail, poor hygiene rapidly increases infection risk, especially from pathogens transmitted by synanthropic species such as rats (e.g. Himsworth et al. 2014). Thus, depending on geographic region and multifarious city factors, urbanization instead of promoting human health can become the gateway through which emergent infectious diseases spread across humanity (Ahmed et al. 2019). Examples abound in the recent literature on how the urbanization process and its indirect effects on surrounding systems can increase the risk of human emerging infectious diseases. Two illustrative examples are those of the Nipah virus and the last few pandemics caused by coronaviruses (e.g. severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS), Middle East respiratory syndrome (MERS)). Human encroachment on Southeast-Asian pristine forests opened the wildlife frontier, increasing interactions between domestic and wildlife animals and allowing viruses to jump into human populations (Olival et al. 2012). It is well known that many wildlife species are important reservoirs of coronaviruses (Anthony et al. 2017). Actually, those that have shown severe human health effects (such as the new coronavirus SARS-CoV-2 responsible for COVID-19) represent a tiny fraction of the diversity of coronaviruses reported in a global mammal survey (Anthony et al. 2017). Although there is a large diversity of coronaviruses, only a few of them have caused worrisome pandemics in the past. Currently, the new coronavirus that has led to COVID-19 has underpinned the ecological consequences of the way we build human settlements, where the aftermath can be huge. Directly transmitted diseases with high mutation rates, such as many viruses, are particularly worrisome in urban systems, where human agglomerations rise and thus represent areas with high host density that are ideal for these types of pathogens. Based on the ‘One Health’ framework (Falzon et al. 2018), which recognizes the interconnections between humans and their environment, and how it is impacted by our activities (currently concentrated in urban centers), it is evident that providing knowledge that ignores the mutlivariate nature of human health often produces spurious conclusions and misleading information. Such is the case of a recently published paper (Wood et al. 2017), which concluded (p. 11): That urbanization might reduce disease is good news for a world that is rapidly urbanizing. Although we do recognize the value in the novelty and scale of Wood et al.’s (2017) paper (together with other similar studies), we strongly encourage the avoidance of misleading statements and gauging conclusions and acknowledge the limitations of their study (which do not necessarily make research results generalizable; e.g. Pienkowski et al. 2017; Aerts, Honnay, and Nieuwenhuyse 2018). Although Wood et al. (2017) do recognize some of the drawbacks of their study across scattered sections of the methods, results, and discussion, they also conclude (p. 12): If there is any broad-brush approach that would simultaneously reduce the burden of multiple infectious diseases, it appears to be the promotion of urbanization and economic development. We consider that such statements are not only misguiding their readers, including stakeholders at different levels of our society, but are also inaccurate. Below we provide some thoughts and facts that put Wood et al.’s (2017) core message into a broader context, emphasizing the limitations of their study based on generalizations from a sample of countries, the proxies used to describe urbanization and biodiversity, and the interpretation of their epidemiological results. Regarding urbanization, it is not crystal clear how ‘urban’ was defined and/or measured as a variable in their analysis. Based on the information provided in their Figure 4, we infer that ‘percent of population living in urban environments’ was their proxy for ‘urban’. If this interpretation holds true, the use of percent urban population brings an important bias that is daunting to control in a global analysis. In fact, the UN (original source for this variable; United Nations 2005) recognizes important variation in the criteria to determine ‘urban’ across countries, which were not considered in Wood et al. (2017)—e.g. total population threshold in Japan is of 50 000 inhabitants, while it is of 200 inhabitants in Norway. Regarding biodiversity, we agree that using proxies is valid when the authors recognize the limitations of using them and contextualize their results accordingly. However, there is a worrisome potential spatial mismatch between the sources of biodiversity (heavily biased by non-urban systems) and those for the epidemiological data (heavily biased by urban systems) used for further analyses. Although Wood et al. (2017) recognize that (p. 3) Another problem with comparing countries is that accuracy in health statistics and reporting varies from country to country. such caution was not exercised when generalizing their findings. We agree that biodiversity in urban areas might not always help to deter zoonosis via dilution effects, which can be pathogen dependent (Brearley et al. 2013; Hassell et al. 2017). In Wood et al. (2017), ‘urban’ was negatively correlated with six directly transmitted diseases related to human density, sanitation and education, among other factors related to modern urbanization and much less with biodiversity. Among the focal diseases in Wood et al. (2017), cysticercosis is related to sanitation measurements and its usual intermediate hosts are domestic animals (e.g. pigs). Also, rabies has been associated with urban synanthropic species (e.g. bats, raccoons) and domestic animals (e.g. dogs). Both examples involve transmission by domestic and synanthropic organisms; hence, they have no relationship with biodiversity proxies. Thus, case-by-case analyses are required when considering such complex interactions, given that no broad–brush approaches are justifiable in light of the multivariate nature of disease ecology. Another important point is that there is no discussion in Wood et al. (2017) regarding the difference between epidemiological hazard and risk (Hosseini et al. 2017). Following Hosseini et al. (2017) ‘A hazard is a potential source of harm, while risk is the likelihood of adverse events (e.g. disease outbreaks) caused by exposure to a hazard (e.g. pathogen)’. For a hazard to turn into a high-risk event, the interactive spatiotemporal associations among relevant variables (i.e. biodiversity, anthropogenic change, pathogens) have to work together, which is highly contingent on host–parasite systems (Rubio et al. 2017). Thus, making generalizations at intermediate levels of organization (i.e. parasite communities) is unreliable (Poulin 2007). The conclusions of Wood et al. (2017) misleadingly suggest that urbanization is positive for human health. Nevertheless, some diseases assessed in their study (e.g. lymphatic filariasis) were actually negatively associated to their biodiversity proxy, which rather supports a dilution effect (as has been previously reported; e.g. Pienkowski et al. 2017). There is growing evidence of the negative role that urban settlements (as complex socio-ecological systems and not as sites where medical services are concentrated) have on human health at different spatiotemporal scales (Grimm et al. 2008; McDonnell and MacGregor-Fors 2016). Thus, we feel it is imperative that future work on this topic includes the nature of the interactions that occur among the three main spheres that comprise cities (i.e. ecological, physical, social). Properly addressing questions in urban systems that can derive in generalizations often require trans-disciplinary approaches, which are needed to tackle relevant topics, such as that of human health (see Wu 2014; Hassell et al. 2017). We are greatly thankful to Mark J. McDonnell and Gerardo Suzán for their thoughtful and wise comments and suggestions, which enhanced the clarity and quality of our commentary. D.S.-A. has been supported by Consejo Nacional de Ciencia y Tecnología (CONACYT, project number Ciencia Básica 2011-01-168524 and project number Problemas Nacionales 2015-01-1628). Conflict of interest statement. None declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Santiago‐Alarcón et al. (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: