Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Classification of administrative decisions as routine, adaptive, and innovative provides the framework for identification of the multiple roles played by city managers. Actual discretion accorded managers by their city councils or by the charter is rated for each category within the adaptive and innovative decision classes in ten cities studied. Such rating of discretion provides more precise descriptions of role behavior than the more customary general description of tasks. The political context for the various ranges of role behavior is then examined for style of politics and institutional-structural factors. Political style may be monopolistic or competitive; institutional-structural factors include popular election of the mayor as opposed to council choice of the mayor, independence of any departments of government from manager control, and ward election of councilmen as opposed to election at large. A positive relationship was found between limitations in range of discretion accorded city managers and popular election of the mayor in all cities with this electoral feature. Restrictions of managers' roles were attributed to conflicting role expectations of the managers and the elected mayors. This finding is in accord with the common-sense opposition of proponents of council-manager government to popular election of the mayor. Gladys M. Kammerer is professor of political science and director of the Public Administration Clearing Service, University of Florida, Gainesville.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gladys M. Kammerer (1964) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: