Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Qualitative comparative analysis reveals critical ideological combinations leading to genocide across regimes, indicating early-warning system implications.
Genocide is among the gravest crimes of political life, yet the scholarly record remains fractured between richly detailed single-case histories and broad structural theories that struggle to explain why ostensibly similar conditions produce catastrophe in one context and quiescence in another. This dissertation addresses that fracture by asking a configurational question: which combinations of ideological frameworks drive regimes not merely toward repression but toward the deliberate destruction of human groups? Drawing on a set-theoretic logic that treats causation as complex, conjunctural, and equifinal, the study conducts a fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis (fsQCA) of sixteen leader-regime cases spanning more than two and a half centuries, from the Qing conquest of the Dzungars in the 1750s to the Darfur campaign of the 2000s. Five ideological conditions are calibrated across all cases: ethnonationalism (ETH), class-based ideology (CLA), colonial extractivism (EXT), religious or ethnic supremacism (SUP), and imperial expansionism (EXP). The outcome measures the severity and completeness of genocidal execution among these confirmed genocidal regimes. The analysis is organized around an original theoretical architecture, the Ideological Prism, which refracts the diffuse concept of “ideology” into three functional modes through which mass violence is rationalized: teleological ideologies (class and empire) that frame destruction as a step toward an inevitable future; existential ideologies (ethnonationalism and supremacism) that construe the targeted group as a mortal threat to the body politic; and utilitarian ideologies (extractivism) that reduce a population to an obstacle standing between the regime and a coveted resource. Synthesizing Moses’s (2008) conception of genocide as a “logic of elimination,” Mann’s (2005) account of the dark side of democracy, and Midlarsky’s (2005) theory of the killing trap, the Prism reframes ideology not as a single variable but as the connective tissue binding state capacity to the will to exterminate. Results indicate that no single ideology is sufficient to explain the most lethal outcomes, but two conditions emerge as individually necessary for high genocidal severity: ethnonationalism (consistency = .93) and colonial extractivism (consistency = .97). The sufficiency analysis identifies two equifinal paths to catastrophic outcomes. The first, ~ETH*CLA*SUP*EXP, describes class-driven regimes fused with supremacist consolidation and explicit eliminationist intent in the relative absence of ethnonationalism, exemplified by Mao’s China and Tojo’s Japan. The second and empirically dominant path, ETH*EXT*SUP*EXP, captures ethnonationalist and expansionist regimes hardened by supremacism and intent, encompassing Hitler, Stalin, Milošević, Enver Pasha, the Qianlong Emperor, and Tsar Alexander II. Both paths achieve perfect consistency (1.0), and together they cover 80% of the outcome. All three hypotheses are supported: the pairing of ethnonationalism and expansionism proves sufficient in non-Marxist regimes (H1); class-based ideology becomes sufficient only when joined to supremacist consolidation (H2); and colonial extractivism generates attritional genocide even in the absence of ethnonationalism (H3). An independent methodological audit confirmed the computational accuracy of every necessity, sufficiency, and hypothesis result while flagging the interpretive limits inherent to a positive-case design, a modest sample, and substantial limited diversity. The study’s contribution is fourfold. Theoretically, it offers a multidimensional, set-theoretic model of genocidal motivation that accommodates causal complexity rather than legislating it away. Empirically, it provides the first systematic fsQCA comparison bridging pre-modern, modern, and contemporary genocides. Methodologically, it demonstrates the analytic purchase of QCA in a field long dominated by narrative case study. Practically, it speaks to the design of early-warning systems and the doctrine of the Responsibility to Protect by specifying the ideological signatures that precede mass atrocity. Read alongside its companion study of impunity dynamics (Pokorny, 2026), the dissertation illuminates both the motivational and the permissive halves of the genocidal equation: why regimes choose to destroy, and why the world so often lets them.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Laszlo Pokorny (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: