Why the study?
Social sport norms often counter medical advice for chronic disease management, forcing chronically ill collegiate athletes to choose between being a good patient or a good athlete.
Highlights the conflict between being a 'good athlete' and a 'good patient' for collegiate athletes with chronic illnesses like type 1 diabetes.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Alerts clinicians to adherence conflicts in collegiate athletes with chronic illness; leaves open targeted interventions for sports settings.
This paper discusses sociological phenomenological challenges faced by chronically ill U.S. collegiate athletes. Using medical sociology frameworks for deviant patients and critical disability approaches to sport, we consider how social sport norms often counter medical advice for chronic disease management, thus forcing athletes to choose between being a ‘good patient’ or being a ‘good athlete’ in the eyes of college sport coaches and sports medicine staff. The definition of athlete ‘health’ conflicts with medical professionals’ understanding of health. Patient compliance and resulting health designate one as a good patient. These definitions of health, in the respective settings, are incompatible, and attempts to fulfil both may be deleterious to athlete health. We theorise issues rooted in the surveillance of college athletes within the Good/Bad athlete/patient framework. To achieve this, we conducted narrative phenomenological analysis of two vignettes from a former NCAA Division I (DI) college women’s basketball athlete, Rubin, detailing her lived experiences as an athlete with diabetes mellitus type 1. These vignettes were created by Rubin over a 2-month period in 2023 from a compilation of 14 autoethnographic reflections written over spring 2022. These were analysed using a structured vignette analysis and including a team of 4 total researchers over a series of 6 separate 1.5-hour reflective analysis meetings. Findings concern sport participation prevention of appropriate management of chronic disease conditions. We forward a new framework for considering the nexus of Athlete/Patient for the purpose of furthering understanding of chronic disease experiences in elite sporting contexts.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Clarke et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: