Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
PERSPECTIVES IN BIOLOGY AND MEDICINE Volume 39 ¦ Number 4 ¦ Summer 1996 EFFECTIVE BLOOD VOLUME: AN EFFECTIVE CONCEPT OR A MODERN MYTH ALASTAIR R. MICHELL * The most crucial problem related to theformation ofedema is the discovery of the criteria by which the kidneys determine whether to accelerate or retard the reabsorption ofsodium.—J. P. Peters [1] There is an engagingly simple explanation for the renal involvement in edema. Occasionally, when the glomeruli leak sufficient protein to reduce plasma albumin, the kidney is the primary cause. Whatever the cause, however , edema formation involves the expansion of the extracellular fluid (ECF) as a whole, with the major compartment (the interstitial fluid, ISF) expanding at the expense of the minor compartment, plasma. This is only feasible because the kidney responds, as with any other cause of hypovolemia , by conserving sodium (and water) in defense of plasma volume. In that sense, edema is an "underfill" phenomenon and the kidney is always its enabling cause. In various circumstances, however, edema fluid accumulates as a consequence of overexpansion of plasma volume, and suspicion then arises that the kidney is its primary cause, i.e., that it is an "overfill" phenomenon. The intervening shades of grey arise from the realization that abnormal escape of intravascular markers of plasma volume could make it appear falsely elevated; moreover, engorgement, for example ofportal capillaries, could increase measured plasma volume without increasing the functional The author thanks Rosemary Forster for preparing this manuscript. *Applied Physiology and Comparative Medicine, The Royal Veterinary College (University of London), Hawkshead Lane, North Mymms, Hatfield, Herts. AL9 7TA, United Kingdom.© 1996 by The University of Chicago. All rights reserved. 0031 _982/96/3903-0949$01.00 Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, 39, 4 ¦ Summer 1996 | 471 volume actually available for circulation. Here lie the seeds of the concept of effective circulating volume which evolved from Peters' concept that the determinant of fluid retention might be "not the actual volume of circulating plasma but some function usually related to the volume of circulating plasma—such as renal blood flow." He reasoned that if edema did occur in instances where blood volume was expanded, "it must be so expanded that the kidneys are unaware of it" [I]. Four years later, Eisenmenger declared that in patients with advanced cirrhosis "despite an elevated total blood volume, the peripheral effective volume appears to be reduced" [2] . In 1958, Papper argued that "The presence ofobvious expansion ofthe totalECF volume in the cirrhotic with ascites does not preclude the possibility of a decreased 'effective' extracellularfluid volume. The 'effective' volume cannot be measured" (instead , its state was inferred from other physiological changes) . He went on, "If, as the evidence suggests, patients with compensated cirrhosis do indeed have a diminished effective extracellular fluid volume, the question arises as to the origin of this diminution in volume" [3] . By 1969, however, Lieberman , et al., were concerned that sodium retention in cirrhotic patients with ascites could not be attributed to a reduced "effective plasma volume" [4] . It is worth noting that from its earliest origins, the concept ofan ' 'effective volume" was applied, almost synonymously, to extracellular fluid, blood, or plasma. The concept of an effective plasma volume (EPV) , different from the total measurement, which has specific importance for the receptors involved in the regulation ofsodium balance and therefore dictates the intensity of sodium retention, is extremely plausible. The problem is that we do not know the receptor site(s) involved to an extent which allows exact prediction or description of the relationship between renal sodium conservation and the accumulation of excess interstitial or ascitic fluid: ' 'Which portion of the ECF is functionally important is unclear; the manner in which changes in the volume of this component are made apparent to the organism is even more uncertain ... if the decreased extracellular fluid volume is a stimulus for sodium retention in decompensated cirrhosis, the receptor system for apprising the kidney of this situation is also unknown" [3]. During the seemingly indefinite interim period, while we await an explanation of the regulation of sodium balance (as opposed to simply the control of renal sodium excretion), "effective plasma volume" serves as a concept which reconciles clinical observations with physiological theory. Or does...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
A.R. Michell (1996) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: