Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Progress in medicine happens in two different ways: with quantum leaps that lead to an essentially radical, but frequently not perfect, change and stepwise changes that modify the big step with easier techniques and better patient-oriented performance. Endoscopically controlled percutaneous stone removal introduced in the late 1970s 1 was such quantum leap. Since than the procedure has been modified by innovations an minimization 2. Size reduction of instruments led to what has become known as mini-percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL). The use of this technique has increased in recent years and it has become the standard approach for most percutaneous kidney stone procedures. The use of smaller instruments in mini-PCNL reduces the risks of haemorrhage and organ injury associated with tract creation and dilation in traditional PCNL. However, mini-PCNL also has disadvantages that are attributable to the smaller tract sizes; these include limited continuous irrigation with hampered endoscopic vision, more time required for stone fragmentation, difficult fragment extraction, and the risk of elevated intrarenal pressure with septic complications. To overcome these deficiencies of mini-PCNL, Prof. Guohua Zeng developed super-mini-PCNL (SMP) 3, 4. The basic components of the SMP system are a miniaturized nephroscope with an irrigation-suction sheath. The two-layered irrigation-suction sheath allows space between the two layers to act as an independent irrigation channel. This frees up the working channel space of the nephroscope, allowing larger instruments to be used without jeopardizing irrigation efficacy. In addition, the sheath allows the inflow and outflow to follow separate channels by following a one-way but continuous flow system. This allows efficient stone removal and a short operating time. The major difference between SMP and ultra-mini-PCNL (UMP) is the way the fragments are managed. In UMP, the stone fragments are flushed out by the recoil of pressurized irrigation, together with rapid removal of the endoscope out of the working sheath. In SMP, most stone fragments are removed by the negative pressure aspiration system, making SMP a highly efficient technique. Combined with the new laser stone dusting disintegration techniques, SMP is likely to become the standard of care. The use of negative pressure aspiration also facilitates irrigation drainage, but at the same time maintains a low average intraluminal pressure throughout the procedure. The clinical outcomes of SMP have been shown to be favourable in previous studies. A well-designed, multicentre, randomized controlled study comparing SMP with flexible ureteroscopy (f-URS) in the treatment of lower pole renal calculi <2 cm showed that SMP was more effective than f-URS in that it was associated with a better stone-free rate and a lower rate of auxiliary procedures to achieve complete stone clearance5. The rate of complications and length of hospital stay were comparable between the two techniques, although f-URS had the advantage of less postoperative pain. SMP can also potentially benefit paediatric patients. There have been concerns that f-URS may be associated with a small but not insignificant risk of injury to the delicate paediatric ureters. Other limitations of f-URS in the paediatric population include the instrument’s short lifespan and the high cost of maintenance. In contrast, SMP is safe and effective for management of renal stones in children, with advantages of short treatment time, high tubeless rate, and effective accessibility to lower pole stones. When compared with shockwave lithotripsy, the use of SMP in selected paediatric patients is able to achieve a higher stone-free rate through a single treatment session and comparable complication rates 6. The basic requirements for a good mini-PCNL system are small-sized endoscope and access sheath that can still offer good entry and exit of the irrigation fluid, a clear visual field, low intraluminal pressure and efficient extraction of stone fragments, with no residual stones. In my opinion, the SMP technique fully meets these requirements. The SMP technique using an irrigation-suction sheath provides a revolutionary approach to improve on the endoscopic vision and stone removal of mini-PCNL. Also, there is no routine need to use a drainage catheter after the procedure. Combining the newly developed, more efficient stone disintegration techniques with the advantages of SMP may provide the opportunity to treat even large renal stones successfully with minimal access. This should be evaluated in future prospective trials. Based on my more than 40 years' experience with percutaneous stone removal and thorough knowledge of the changes that were introduced, I think it can justifiably be stated that the SMP technique represents the most significant progress in this field, and it will likely become the dominant method for percutaneous stone management in future. Open access funding enabled and organized by Project DEAL. None declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
P. Alken (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: