Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Cross-disciplinary research has become both a promise and a puzzle for the field of communication—a discipline that celebrates boundary-crossing yet continually reflects on its unique contributions and distinct identity. Drawing on a survey of 278 editorial board members from leading communication journals, this study examines how a sample of researchers occupying key mentorship and gatekeeping roles conceptualize and practice cross-disciplinarity across academic lineages: their advisors, themselves, and their advisees. Results reveal widespread support for cross-disciplinary engagement, with most respondents describing their own work as bringing together ideas from different fields. However, further coding indicated that most scholars engage primarily in multidisciplinary rather than interdisciplinary or transdisciplinary forms of scholarship. Respondents viewed themselves and their advisees as more cross-disciplinary than communication scholars in general and their advisors, respectively, while also perceiving junior scholars, doctoral students, and funders as more supportive of cross-disciplinary work than journal editors and senior scholars. Qualitative findings further highlighted themes of disciplinary identity negotiation, institutional tensions, collaborative knowledge production, and the perceived importance of cross-disciplinary research for the field’s relevance and impact. Together, the findings portray a discipline that strongly values cross-disciplinary ideals while continuing to negotiate their meaning and implementation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Zier et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: