Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We offer a new way of thinking about remainder economies in this special issue on ‘gleaning’ (the practice of claiming leftovers). We trace how people in many different places and times justify taking leftovers by claiming to seek some higher social end, over and above their own private interest. Gleaners take useful scraps not just by right but also by obligation: they assert both an entitlement to things that are too accidental, insignificant, or indeterminate to be privatized and a responsibility to see that this shared material is well managed. As such, gleaning cracks private property open to collectivist claims; it opens up holistic social imaginaries. Asserting the right to take scraps situates speakers as part owners of the whole from which scraps come. The essays collected here show this logic at work across many different social settings, from twenty-first-century cities and artisanal gold mines to twentieth-century socialist and Fordist factories, and all the way back to early Christian monasticism. Together, they ask us to think beyond liberal private property logics by dwelling in the indeterminate gap where worthless things are still useful. Shifting attention from circulation and value to the entitlements and obligations remainders make possible, we take gleaning seriously as a way to understand how these claims continue to function today. This project has made us realize how many pockets of indeterminate property there still are in the world, and we hope the same for you.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bize et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: