Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The Metaphysics of Evolution:From Aquinas's Interpretation of Augustine's Concept of Rationes Seminales to the Contemporary Thomistic Account of Species Transformism1 Mariusz Tabaczek O.P. Introduction One of the most important aspects of Augustine's De Genesi ad litteram libri duodecim is his concept of rationes seminales, which enabled him to assert that although God created everything instantaneously, in the initial state of the universe all species were present in the potency of the primordial matter, to be actualized at the consecutive stages of the history of its development.2 Interpreted by St. George Jackson Mivart (1827–1900), John Zahm, C.S.C (1851–1921), and Henri de Dorlodot [End Page 945] (1855–1929) as an early anticipation of the theory of evolution, the idea of rationes seminales did not find much appreciation on the side of the father of the nineteenth-century revolution in biology—Charles Darwin. The fact is that Augustine's theory did not assume a gradual transformation of one species into another. Such transition would not be acceptable within the context of the neo-Platonic definition of forms as fixed ideas in the mind of God, participated by created beings. Moreover, it seems that speaking of the actualization of rationes seminales, Augustine assumed two possibilities: they either (1) have a natural potential to gradually develop (unfold), under proper conditions, to the fullness of maturity, or (2) provide a proper ground (occasion) for God's instantaneous and direct (ordinary or special) intervention effecting an instantaneous appearance of the first representative of a given species in its adult form.3 Needless to say, [End Page 946] the latter option is unacceptable and becomes a stumbling block for the proponents of the modern evolutionary synthesis. Thomas Aquinas refers to Augustine's rationes seminales on several occasions in his commentary on the work of six days in Summa theologiae, and in his other works, seemingly accepting the idea of all species (except for human species) being virtually present in the outcome of the initial act of creation, as well as accepting both possibilities of their actualization—through gradual development and through instantaneous and direct divine intervention. Assuming his theology in this matter follows faithfully the original thought of Augustine, it might be considered as being unable to fit within the context of the contemporary version of the evolutionary theory. However, we must not forget that Aquinas's reference to Augustine's concept of rationes seminales was accompanied by his general acceptance of Aristotle's moderate realism about universals, including species, grounded in his hylomorphic metaphysics of substance. This fact provides an opportunity for redefining Augustine's concept of rationes seminales in terms of the hylomorphic theory of matter, which—in turn—enables it to accommodate the idea of the gradual transformation of species. The main goal of this article is to develop such reinterpretation. In order to reach this goal, we will begin, in the first section, with the general presentation of Augustine's notion of creation in his De Genesi ad litteram libri duodecim and the short reflection upon the motives that inspired his introducing the concept of rationes seminales. The exact understanding [End Page 947] of this concept in Augustine's theology is the subject of our investigation in our second section, which is then followed by a third section critically evaluating some early tendencies of regarding it as evolutionary. The fourth and fifth sections introduce the main objectives of Aquinas's reflection and interpretation of the account of the work of six days found in Genesis, as well as his use of Augustine's notion of rationes seminales. Next, in our sixth section, we develop and provide a constructive proposal of the Thomistic metaphysics of evolutionary transformism, which is then followed by our constructive proposal of the redefinition of the concept of rationes seminales in the seventh section. The article closes with the evaluation of the faithfulness of the proposed model to the core principles of the Aristotelian-Thomistic system of metaphysics and philosophical theology, as well as its relevance in the context of contemporary science. Augustine's Notion of Creation The point of departure for our analysis is the thought of Augustine...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mariusz Tabaczek (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: