This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
I can think of few activities more enervating emotionally than to survey the psychological literature on sex differences. I first did so about 15 years ago, soon after the birth of contemporary American feminism, and was taken aback by the gap between the actual, enfeebled state of our knowledge, and the dogmatic self-assertion of so much then being written on the topic. Since that time, things both have and have not changed. What has changed is the sheer quantity of work done or in progress, a dearth having become a glut; what has not changed is our depth of understanding. The abundance of new data has produced no breakthroughs, no new insights, and few bases for changes of heart or mind. If you believed fifteen years ago that sex differences, the important ones, were at bottom biological in origin, you would have no compelling reason to believe otherwise today. If you were a doctrinaire environmentalist then, you would still be so today. In either case, you could muster far more support for your position than previously, as in fact you could for all positions between the extremes. So one major reason to be dispirited is the strong sense one gets of a discipline merely treading water-it is depressing to read through dozens of laborious articles reporting minor variations on this or that empirical theme, to find that in the end they add up to little in the way of enhanced understanding. To some considerable degree, these problems reflect a larger set of problems we find in social science generally: given a complex topic, it is extraordinarily difficult to obtain secure, non-trivial findings, and to articulate compelling or even heuristic theoretical models. The optimism we once had about the powers of social science, our belief that it would soon clarify and help resolve a wide range of social and psychological troubles-that optimism, so strongly felt in the 1950's and 1960's, now seems heady if not utopian. Yet these generic problems are compounded, within the do-
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Joseph Adelson (1986) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: