Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Power spectral analysis of heart rate variability should not be viewed as an infallible surrogate for direct measures of autonomic nervous system function.
Dear Editor-in-Chief: I write to express concern that the authors of "Respiratory sinus arrhythmia and cardiovascular neural regulation in athletes" (Med. Sci. Sports Exerc. 30:215-219, 1998) (8) are iterating a prevalent but controversial theory: that changes in sympathetic cardiac control are related directly (and therefore interpretable quantitatively) to changes in low-frequency heart rate oscillations. In the introduction, the authors describe the low-frequency oscillations derived from spectral analysis of heart rate as, "a low-frequency component (ranging between 0.04 and 0.15 Hz), which reflects sympathetic and parasympathetic control and always increases during sympathetic activation." Although it seems clear that low-frequency heart rate oscillations are mediated by both branches of the autonomic nervous system (1), the assertion that increases in low-frequency power and sympathetic activity are related directly is contradicted by published data. Saul et al. (7) increased sympathetic neural outflow with nitroprusside infusions and reported highly variable individual responses. Significant correlations between muscle sympathetic nerve activity and low-frequency power (absolute and normalized) were found for only 5 of 10 subjects. Iwase et al. (4) clearly demonstrated that muscle sympathetic nerve activity increases linearly as a function of the sine of the tilt angle during graded head-up tilt, and yet Mukai and Hayano (6) found that low-frequency heart rate variability increases significantly only up to 30° and then levels off or falls slightly at 45, 60, and 90°. In our laboratory, we recently observed no change in low-frequency R-R interval spectral power and linear increases in muscle sympathetic nerve activity (bursts/min) in seven healthy subjects during 20, 40, 60, and 70° tilt (unpublished observations). In the discussion section of Strano et al. (8), the authors suggest that variable respiratory rates preclude interpretation of sympathetic activity because low-frequency peaks are obscured. An alternative or complementary view is that interpretation of sympathetic activity is impossible because low-frequency heart rate oscillations do not reflect directly sympathetic cardiac control. Kingwell et al. (5) found no significant correlation between 0.1-Hz R-R interval spectral power and cardiac norepinephrine spillover. Hopf et al. (3) blocked sympathetic cardiac outflow with thoracic anesthesia, but low-frequency R-R interval spectral power was unaffected at rest and during tilt. Both Kingwell et al. (5) and Hopf et al. (3) concluded that the modulation of low-frequency heart rate fluctuations is multifactorial and that spectral analyses cannot be used as simple indexes of sympathetic outflow. The notion that "autonomic balance" can be quantified from measures of heart rate variability has recently been challenged (2). In light of evidence to the contrary, it seems inappropriate and misleading to assume such a complete understanding of autonomic oscillators as to suggest that sympathetic efferent outflow to the heart is always reflected in low-frequency heart rate power spectra. It is important to realize that although power spectral analysis is a powerful tool to investigate autonomic neural regulation, it should not be viewed as an infallible surrogate for direct measures of autonomic nervous system function. William H. Cooke, Ph.D. McGuire Veterans Affairs Medical Center; Richmond, VA 23249
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
William H. Cooke (1998) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: