Key result
Baseline adjustment in pharmacogenomic GWAS introduces bias, yielding ~2-fold more false-positive loci for statin response.
Cohort (n=34,874)
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In pharmacogenomic studies of quantitative change, any association between genetic variants and the pretreatment (baseline) measurement can bias the estimate of effect between those variants and drug response. A putative solution is to adjust for baseline. We conducted a series of genome-wide association studies (GWASs) for low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) response to statin therapy in 34,874 participants of the Genetic Epidemiology Research on Adult Health and Aging (GERA) cohort as a case study to investigate the impact of baseline adjustment on results generated from pharmacogenomic studies of quantitative change. Across phenotypes of statin-induced LDL-C change, baseline adjustment identified variants from six loci meeting genome-wide significance ( SORT/CELSR2/PSRC1, LPA, SLCO1B1, APOE, APOB , and SMARCA4 / LDLR ). In contrast, baseline-unadjusted analyses yielded variants from three loci meeting the criteria for genome-wide significance ( LPA , APOE , and SLCO1B1 ). A genome-wide heterogeneity test of baseline versus statin on-treatment LDL-C levels was performed as the definitive test for the true effect of genetic variants on statin-induced LDL-C change. These findings were generally consistent with the models not adjusting for baseline signifying that genome-wide significant hits generated only from baseline-adjusted analyses ( SORT/CELSR2/PSRC1, APOB, SMARCA4 / LDLR ) were likely biased. We then comprehensively reviewed published GWASs of drug-induced quantitative change and discovered that more than half (59%) inappropriately adjusted for baseline. Altogether, we demonstrate that (1) baseline adjustment introduces bias in pharmacogenomic studies of quantitative change and (2) this erroneous methodology is highly prevalent. We conclude that it is critical to avoid this common statistical approach in future pharmacogenomic studies of quantitative change.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Oni‐Orisan et al. (2020) conducted a cohort in Low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) response to statin therapy (n=34,874). Baseline adjustment in pharmacogenomic GWAS vs. Baseline-unadjusted analyses was evaluated on Genetic variants meeting genome-wide significance for statin-induced LDL-C change. Adjusting for baseline in pharmacogenomic GWAS of quantitative change introduces bias, yielding 6 genome-wide significant loci compared to 3 loci in unadjusted analyses.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: