Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
While women account for a proportionately low percentage of violent crime in South Africa, these acts often attract sensationalised media attention. The pathologisation and demonisation of ‘violent women’ obscure their pathways to violence and reinforce stereotypical notions of femininities. These societal discourses also silence the particular meanings which women attach to their life experiences both before and during incarceration. This article explores the life history narratives of women who were incarcerated for crimes including murder, attempted murder, culpable homicide and robbery with aggravating circumstances. The aim of the study was to investigate women's accounts of their crimes and the meanings which they attached to them. This article reports on a subsample of six women who were interviewed with regard to the crimes which had led to their incarceration. Two open-ended narrative interviews were conducted with each participant in a prison in the Western Cape Province of South Africa. A narrative analysis of the data examined both the form and content of the life narratives and illustrated how the participants made sense of their life experiences. In particular, these narratives highlighted the positive meanings which they attached to incarceration. These conversion narratives were typified by the transformation of protagonists from bad girls into good women. The narratives were characterised by the redemptive aspects of incarceration and strongly drew on prison discourses of rehabilitation and change. The accounts also drew on societal discourses of stereotypical femininity thereby relegating aggression and violence to a masculine domain. Thus good women were neither aggressive nor violent and narrators contrasted these protagonists with the bad girl personas which existed prior to incarceration. These transformations were not uncomplicated and were typified by tensions between protagonists who partly used aggression and violence as survival mechanisms and rehabilitated protagonists who were expected to behave in stereotypically feminine ways. The study illustrated how these women's narratives were shaped by prison and broader societal discourses.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Adelene Africa (2015) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: