Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Some years before the Good Friday Agreement, Michael Gallagher addressed a key dilemma in Northern Ireland politics. In two seminal articles, he raised central normative and empirical questions embodied in the titles of two articles: ‘Do Ulster unionists have a right to self-determination?’ (1990) and ‘How many nations are there in Ireland?’ (1995). On the first question, Gallagher comprehensively explored theories of national self-determination and decolonisation before concluding that ‘the very idea of an absolute right to self-determination for either nationalists or unionists is a chimera’. On the second question, following an assessment of the case for a one-nation or a two-nation island, and assessing the notion of ‘partial’ or not fully formed nations, he concluded that a type of ‘three nations theory’, distinguishing between ‘Irish’, ‘British’ and ‘Ulster’ identities, performed better than the alternatives. This article revisits these debates a generation later, in the light of major changes in demography, identity and geopolitics. It uses contemporary survey, census and other data to assess the extent of ethnopolitical change since the late twentieth century, and explores the implications of change for collective choice on the island of Ireland in matters pertaining to national identity.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
John Coakley (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: