Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The notion of ‘justice for victims’ of the most serious crimes has been at the center of the normative developments that we have come to know as transitional justice. Indeed, the social movements that were the engine for this prodigious change in social and state practices and later also in international standards succeeded initially in persuading larger circles of society, and eventually state institutions as well, that newly democratic dispensations could not ignore the plight of the victims of human rights crimes of the recent past. Human rights organizations pleaded to reject oblivion, false ‘reconciliation’ and forgiving and forgetting. Their stand soon became a forceful demand for affirmative measures to ensure that victims, survivors and their families would now be recognized as first-class citizens with specific rights and entitlements. Through decisions of domestic and international tribunals, those policy measures became recognized as treaty-based obligations that the state owes victims, summarized in the objectives of truth, justice, reparations and measures of nonrepetition. Victims and survivors were, of course, present and active at the outset of this remarkable movement. ‘Justice for victims’ might at first have given the impression that those who had been harmed by abuse of state power were to be passive recipients of the benefits of truth seeking, truth telling and reparations. In practice, however, victims and survivors became prominent protagonists of these exercises in public policy measures designed to infuse specific content to the promise that such crimes would ‘never again’ occur. It is for that reason that transitional justice today requires victims’ participation in the design and execution of all programs of truth telling and reparations, and not simply as witnesses or recipients of benefits. Indeed, victims’ active participation is also a requirement for justice in the form of prosecutions. In interpreting modern international law standards, authoritative organs of protection demand that domestic courts and codes of criminal procedure allow for victim participation in the investigation, prosecution and trial of international crimes. The same can be said about measures of nonrepetition: their success in ‘vetting’ institutions and excluding those in them who have abused their power depends to a large extent on the degree to which victims have a say in creating a fair and complete process, including the design of adequate horizontal and vertical controls over those institutions, as well as training and continuing education of their members. The requirement of victim participation has become a well-established norm, perhaps not as a sine qua non obligation on the part of states that embark on transitional justice exercises, but certainly as a measuring stick for their effectiveness and as predictors of their chances of success. Perhaps one could even go further and posit that the degree to which transitional justice schemes involve active victim and survivor participation in their design, planning and execution is an indication of the good faith and due diligence with which governments face the challenge of truth, justice and memory for human rights crimes. In true dialectic fashion – as is the case in all matters related to transitional justice – the norm development that requires victim participation is inspired by the best practices of recent years and, at the same time, has generated ever richer and more sophisticated practices that go beyond attempts to do justice only in domestic settings. International criminal justice organs have also diversified and increased their approaches to victim participation in investigation, prosecution and trial, as well as in witness protection and emergency and long-term reparations. By any measure, these practices continue to evolve and to yield important lessons that need to be analyzed and studied. Not all of them are necessarily ‘best practices,’ so it is important to subject them to rigorous examination. Both good and bad practices, in any event, have to be analyzed since we learn lessons from success as well as from failure. New issues and dilemmas appear to the scholar and the practitioner with each new attempt to enrich our knowledge of transitional justice through the lens of all stakeholders, and principally the viewpoints of victims and survivors. An important issue is the degree to which public policy can determine in all fairness who is an ‘innocent’ victim and even whether that categorization is necessary in framing the scope of transitional justice mechanisms. In complex scenarios, individuals and communities often share responsibilities for tragic situations and many may have been both victims and perpetrators of abuses. Should the transitional justice mechanism ignore that fact and treat all as ‘innocent’? Or should it instead demand an exacting qualification as a ‘clean hands’ victim before allowing participation or benefits? Refusal to recognize agency in victims of human rights abuses could demean their dignity and be a throwback to passivity, denying their involvement in providing accountability for the crimes they suffered. It is crucial also to contemplate different forms of ‘victimhood,’ since the experience of suffering is not limited to that of persons who are directly targeted for murder, arbitrary arrest, forced disappearance or torture. Their next of kin and even members of the community to which the direct victims belong also suffer in various ways. In addition, it is essential to recognize that the perpetrators’ selection of targets is frequently related to deeper injustices and marginalization in society. In fact, victims of international crimes are almost always first denied ‘citizenship’ in the true sense of the word, and then victimized. Their vindication as first-class citizens is a key objective of reparations, as well as of the other aspects of transitional justice. For that reason, programs to vindicate them must consider their original status in society, including their membership in communities subjected to ancestral discrimination. In addition, victim and survivor participation in transitional justice mechanisms must be gender sensitive in determining who qualifies for reparations and in what scope and amount, as well as in facilitating the proper participation of women and children in the process by which the universe of victims and survivors is determined and selected. In both domestic and international trials, the direct and indirect victims of the crime being prosecuted should be heard, not only as witnesses but also in making legal arguments, offering evidence and more generally moving the process forward. Some legal systems have fairly sophisticated procedural norms about the participation of crime victims as parti civil or as ‘private prosecutor.’ Although domestic law and practices vary extensively on this matter, when it comes to international crimes the state is obliged to allow a very expansive form of participation. This is the case in international criminal justice as well, as demonstrated in the practice of the International Criminal Court (ICC). Indeed, victims’ groups will continue to contribute to justice through their capacity to mobilize and bring to the courthouse the views of sectors of civil society affected by the process. But mobilization and demonstrations can disrupt court hearings and result in undue pressures on independent and impartial state institutions and could eventually threaten the very notion of the rule of law. It is therefore important for the views of victims to be represented not only through demonstrations and statements by their natural leaders, but also through the orderly processes of participation as allowed in criminal procedure. In the realm of reparations, determining their scope and quantum very often brings up issues of their relationship with development assistance and welfare benefits to be enjoyed by larger categories of citizens. As far as possible, reparations must attempt to redress egregious wrongs and restore the victim to the status quo ante . But care must be exercised to avoid creating newly unfair distinctions between impoverished and disenfranchised members of society and, indeed, between communities of the downtrodden. This brings up the dilemmas of making reparations truly ‘restorative’ while at the same time making them serve the purpose of preventing future conflict and its ensuing legacy of human rights violations. Since transitional justice takes place in circumstances in which the previously powerful leaders and agents of a repressive regime have lost power but have not left the scene, the actions undertaken to provide accountability for their crimes frequently bring up confrontations between victims and their victimizers, both in the specific scenarios created by transitional justice mechanisms as well as in the course of ordinary and even banal moments in daily life. The power relationship between a torturer and his victim lingers long after the torture session ends, either in the psychology of the participants or in societal attitudes towards them that are not always and not everywhere linear or one-dimensional. There is a crucial relationship between this phenomenon and the endless variations to be seen in real life between continuity of the repressive government (with or without diminished violations), change of government and ‘regime change.’ As in all other aspects of transitional justice, participation by victims and survivors alters the equation when the transition is not from dictatorship to democracy but from armed conflict to peace. Victim and survivor participation is also affected by the fact that there are multiple perpetrators and multiple categories of victims. Nevertheless, an important legacy of more than three decades of transitional justice is that affected communities ought to be heard in the context of peace negotiations, for they will have to live with the consequences of peace deals that may be just or unjust, even as they had to live (and die) with a war that was mostly not of their making. The above listing of issues suggested by the roles of victims and survivors in transitional justice is by no means exhaustive. However, it would be glaringly incomplete without mention of the construction and preservation of memory. This has become a central feature of transitional justice even if not a specific legal obligation mandated by international law. Most importantly, victim participation in the construction and preservation of memory is achieving a central place in determining what must be remembered, by whom and how. Memory will not settle differences in the interpretation of history, nor should it attempt to do so. But active and engaged participation by victims and survivors ensures that the memory is not incomplete or biased and, above all, guarantees that ‘impermissible lies’ will not be allowed to remain a part of the historical record. 1 All of these themes, and several more, are examined in the articles that make up this special issue. In addition, they examine those matters in the context of the most exciting and complicated experiments with justice for international crimes that are at play in today’s world. The legacy of genocide in Cambodia (Julie Bernath) is placed alongside the efforts to avoid impunity for the crimes in Bosnia and Herzegovina (Janine Clark). The complex and thorny dilemma of how to put an end to generations-long armed conflict while vindicating the rights of victims to see justice done is examined in articles about Colombia (Pilar Riaño Alcalá and María Victoria Uribe), Afghanistan (Huma Saeed) and the Democratic Republic of Congo (Peter Dixon). Brazil (Tessa Lacerda) is the subject of an essay about achieving accountability after decades of impunity for crimes that took place 40 or more years ago. Nepal (Tazreena Sajjad) and South Africa (Gertrude Fester-Wicomb) are analyzed for the still-unresolved rights of victims even where significant transitional justice has been achieved. One article also approaches current discussions about the application of the law of armed conflict to victims’ rights and to the ICC’s work in that regard (Emily Camins). A number of articles approach victims’ rights from a more theoretical framework (Margaret Walker and Luke Moffett), not related to any particular country or situation but based on a firm grasp of empirical data and frontline experience. In all cases, the central theme is the role of the victim in transitional justice. It is a felicitous choice of topic on the part of the editors-in-chief of the Journal, and I feel honored and grateful for being given the opportunity to collaborate with this prestigious publication in the role of guest editor. Needless to say, the editors-in-chief and the managing editor did much more than invite me to edit this special issue. Their advice and support has been indispensable and invariably wise and supportive. I should also mention the incisive comments and insight contributed by the peer reviewers who read and commented on specific articles. If there is one regret, it is that space forced us to make some very difficult choices among many highly deserving submissions, several of them covering stimulating areas related to transitional justice and victims. It has been a great adventure to guest-edit this issue of the Journal. I am confident that the reader has access here to a selection of illuminating and thoughtful contributions by various serious thinkers in our field. My colleagues at the Journal and I welcome your comments. Note from the Editors: With this issue, we say goodbye to Co-EIC Laurel E. Fletcher who finished a five-year term in December 2015. We are deeply grateful for her editorial vision and service as well as the institutional support of Berkeley Law. We welcome M. Brinton Lykes as the new Co-EIC. She is a leading scholar and professor of community-cultural psychology at the Lynch School of Education and Associate Director of the Center for Human Rights & International Justice at Boston College. From 2016, the Journal will be run as a collaborative project between the Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation and the Center for Human Rights & International Justice.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Juan E. Méndez (2016) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: