Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This manuscript presents a comparison of research paradigms and emphases during the first century of formalized mammalogy in North America. To accomplish this task, it became necessary to investigate not only the transformations in “research methods” (techniques or technological advances) over the last 100 years, but to address the evolution of the “state-of-the-science” (new and shifting paradigms, more sophisticated hypotheses, and origin of new subdisciplines). As we constructed this chapter, it became apparent that in many cases, these two areas were intertwined and typically dependent on each other. For example, the advent of new technologies often allows the testing of more sophisticated hypotheses, which then leads to the next generation of research methods, hypotheses, and so on. Consequently, although our goal was to treat “methods” and “paradigms” as separate foci, it became necessary, on occasion, to discuss the two simultaneously. We have organized our chapter into three sections. The first section pertains to “Changes in Emphases and Paradigms.” There, we describe how mammalogy changed from a purely descriptive and exploratory process to one that became more taxonomically focused in scope and more narrowly directed at testing specific hypotheses. This section also includes a discussion of how “integrated approaches” (multi-authored research endeavors and multiple data sets) and the evolution of “species concepts” changed the science of mammalogy. The second section, “Advancements in Research Methods as a Result of New Technology,” addresses the changes in equipment, techniques, and data analyses, and ultimately, how these innovations impacted the science of mammalogy. In the third and final section, “Literature Review,” we contrasted manuscripts that were published in the Journal of Mammalogy during the first 10 years of its existence (1919–1928) and middle 10 years (1960–1969) to manuscripts that appeared more recently (2007–2016). We categorized manuscripts into various disciplines to see if activity in those disciplines remained constant since the inception of the Journal of Mammalogy. Further, by using manuscripts that were published in the Journal of Mammalogy during these three time frames, we hoped to identify the types of “mammalogy” that the American Society of Mammalogists, through its Editorial Board, reviewers, and membership (those submitting manuscripts), considered “acceptable and contemporary mammalogy.” For much of our chapter, we drew heavily upon previous contributions that appeared in Seventy-five Years of Mammalogy (1919–1994) edited by Elmer C. Birney and Jerry R. Choate (Birney and Choate 1994). In particular, the section entitled “Intellectual Development of the Science of Mammalogy” proved extremely useful in preparing a synopsis of how mammalogy has advanced as a science during its first century as a professional discipline. Other sources such as Going Afield (Phillips and Jones 2005), United States Biological Survey: A Compendium of its History, Personalities, Impacts, and Conflicts (Schmidly et al. 2016) and A Timeline of Significant Events in the Development of North American Mammalogy (Schmidly et al. 2017) proved invaluable in our endeavor to reconstruct the science of mammalogy of previous generations and to dissect the events that would shape current research in the discipline. From the late 1800s to the middle part of the 20th century, mammalogy was dominated by specimen-based and field-based research. For much of this period, mammalogy was a descriptive science with little, if any, commitment to hypothesis-based research. In many ways, this is not surprising and should not be considered as a negative connotation to the quality of mammalogy as a science during its onset. It was simply the state-of-the-discipline at a given point in time, and as with most scientific endeavors, these early descriptive and specimen-based studies (range distributions, taxonomic treatments of species and subspecies, natural history characteristics, etc.) provided the data for later (contemporary) discussions about phylogeography, vicariance, dispersal, speciation, and a myriad of other factors that have influenced the mammalian diversity of North America. Further, modern genetic methods (e.g., mtDNA, microsatellites) and analytical approaches such as phylogeography have challenged these ideas and in some cases strengthened the early arguments and positions. Three obvious factors appear to have contributed to the descriptive nature of the early years of mammalian research in North America. First, one could surmise that the personalities of Merriam’s men and the Merriam’s during the of the of Biological the of mammalogy as a science at the time of the of the or the of the 2016) was to the North American and distributions, of and and and given a in of taxonomic a was on that many of the of the the of the through as of the and of the Journal of Mammalogy a on specimen-based and field-based research. were and to at this Merriam’s were more or a of the In a a for how field-based research was to be and at the that remained for was by that a in the early of mammalogy as or by the to a more descriptive to the and typically were in As C. and of at the in as by it is not to see this on mammalogy. Further, those as by not in the as the by at the of at to and the United States by research the of North American during the late 1800s and early that was necessary to a of North American as as to a scope of and As by et al. of North was a natural of of the The of and Mammalogy and the were the first to to this for taxonomic The not only to of but many of the first on the natural and of in the United and In the North American as for studies and data that from the the of the at the a taxonomic and data was for of North and as as for some of the of et al. for a the at by and other and American of to to studies of mammalian these studies remained the to from studies of and taxonomic to the of and with the of history studies to the modern were as to the and other of the mammalian of North America. was to the of mammalogy could as a simply early were by the and at In the a of a a of and a scope or were considered for this early of were in of and or in those with most to testing and etc.) and or and this to descriptive and and studies to mammalian research from the the late and early is not to that the disciplines of and were not in more of a natural history as were more and by the of technologies were the more descriptive of time were the of R. and during the through the the of and studies Further, a of at the a to with studies The of and in and in the into the the of in mammalian research and the of and ideas or were that and (e.g., contributions by R. and but in were to the for the of research. more sophisticated methods and hypothesis-based in as could be and using new with the of the modern and to to and and and and and to a of the that the ideas in modern could that these events a from specimen-based research a more science for and in many This research more of on a of a data from became more the of over hypothesis-based research focused on a or only a on the scope of the Consequently, and to more in of taxonomic and often in studies to of and that the research. the part of this and shape the of by and to mammalian research. studies on and many other in the modern of and (e.g., and and the and see and the for and and in to taxonomic during previous descriptive studies using descriptive mammalogy a as of taxonomic by et al. as data were to for This into the early the on specimen-based research as and and the of became in mammalogy. In the and the of new ideas and such as published in but into in of and and and and and and et al. to a research as and were For example, the from and to the that and and published the first Journal of Mammalogy on and into a of its with the of C. and For the first time, methods were to to a to to studies and a on the of and the Journal of Mammalogy to and such as and and to a of mammalian and and et al. and for a synopsis of and with on methods to identify at various taxonomic of and to for that to In these new genetic methods with previous in of and to new methods for the of and and for a of other genetic et al. Further, the data to a by and for and that were on from on data (e.g., those advanced by and to and reconstruct through and or As with these new genetic methods and the to to a of and was at its the technological in for and methods to be at research North America. such as analyses, and heavily impacted research. phylogeography, and to the of new scientific disciplines (e.g., and the the and and provided a to on descriptive and specimen-based to species and In with the of the a new for research. the were for of the of and data were to multiple and a myriad of with to the technological with in the at the data from such at most the sophisticated equipment, most to a or that the and the The to the is often of data on some The then a and the data in with the research has the current generation of to more in data and data It be to see methods the of mammalogy. In this section, we on the changes in the of mammalogy to the in and diversity of data of data sets) in a research In to this in of has a in the of with these the it is that multiple data and the more data in a the the for and we discuss this in data and to a the for this To accomplish we the Journal of Mammalogy during three time the first 10 years of middle 10 years and a of 10 years and the of of manuscripts multiple data of manuscripts with two or more and of discipline. the of manuscripts was the of multiple data proved to be more we a which the data to be in to as a For example, a manuscript in which a was and a data was as one of data in this if a was and a was it was as a In our to the of other the of manuscripts on the of the most research a as and were by a For example, appeared in the Journal of Mammalogy during the first 10 years of and of these be as a data or and were the middle time the of remained of the of of during the 10 years the of to of and were of of manuscript types and as of multiple data and natural history and and and and in and of the in of manuscript types and as of multiple data and natural history and and and and in and of the in this We that this has by at three First, the in multiple and of multiple sources of data is not surprising given the from descriptive research to more research. This leads to and more multiple and to the with have new or more sophisticated be as the scientific to more research methods by new technologies and it became more for a to be or be in new research As each new a has two and the new or a of the new methods to or research. of of the Journal of Mammalogy a of and methods in research. To this research to and in and and a of other be in of these or be the to of these research for and more The last years have a in and for to for a of As a be more sophisticated and more of and multiple of the more and to with the the of In many have research for that the manuscript be with a on multiple data a that be in the or be research This is not to it is process of its scientific disciplines have through a of more sophisticated over In many ways, this is the part of as new technologies one to new or address To it a species or is the For so to the of we have with a species or species that is and this into as and species that have at various by As we with a species to our taxonomic but as we more as we to to is a how and how the It is of some to that C. one of the most in with this as In in the first of the Journal of on the for the of and In that methods have one on the or of the other on the of of the in a using the of or as for taxonomic and that the of is the more Further, that from is the of the these three in mammalogy as we to investigate for methods and to how much is of etc.) is to two as and if we have data to our the by the with is a the of that of of from the that from the of from those to the of the for the of the is to the existence or of and to in the of as to the of necessary to the of species and into the and of species in we have the most in mammalogy our and discuss how the of these and has not only over time but how these have impacted and influenced the of mammalogy. In the of these species we not (those that to or a and as those arguments the scope of this The to as the or species is one of the and in This be to and and is on the that if a identify a two then for or two In many ways, the of modern and taxonomic upon the of the and of research. For example, the the of a to as a or for a or other taxonomic on the of comparison other to the a be as to or not the of and many other from this The of the is in the of to a and the to a is or it is it in the of or The was the for mammalogy during the early years of and specimen-based into and the of this is by contemporary (e.g., of would to this as of The Biological has one of the most species in by and later by and the a species as a of natural that is from other such most were that the with in the of and how to with how to was one of the most species in mammalogy the it to be by of the The in its a species as the of which is a of and The has one of the most and of the species with three and and and and and The as a for species if have a of the the not the species it to and see and for a discussion of the of the the species The became one of the most species during the and to be one of the more species The was first by and later by and if from each that be as for of and as that separate two to this First, genetic these early a as to how genetic could as the for species and species not have a for genetic on the scientific methods at that the advent of and or could be and to if or were is this in The in by and and and its in mammalian and for using modern genetic data as a or for genetic two the be as a many of the by and for its a and more in with a on the of and in taxonomically focused in the Journal of the is one of the most species in mammalian research. so often in that to scientific in a in or we a of the technological and describe on the of mammalogy. is by and the time we in many cases, on and in the mammalian It would be and to that these were for mammalian research. most were in or in research but were by the for the next or For some technological often is a as the or to be at a or in a natural history as a new has it first at the research and then to the research as a of research In this section, we on new methods and on ideas that have the in data with or other of data (e.g., of these were for have more of on research other on and other to to the each of these methods has its and in the advent of the research on were to the United States from in and were first in for was first by for to the of in but the first in the Journal of Mammalogy was in and field-based studies that of have that Jones et al. the of and on how to in and to As the was for the of a second for the was The of this in over in were over the years, and in and The of in many in and species of over of only (e.g., and of various have in mammalogy to of most were in to or not the in and the the advent of the in the provided the with a that could be or in This became in the the time that (e.g., were at but (e.g., became for studies of The of has since the genetic methods Methods such as and the as often were for For the for and and provided methods for other methods for with and of This a part of a on a For example, on the of the research be if or is to the were to of on of the The most using a that a The is the and allows to be the is by to a that the Other methods of and of these has and of The advent of in the late provided technological to to and through of the were on of and The first in the Journal of Mammalogy using was on activity The to of or became a in mammalian research on by to as the of and with the and for data analytical for and recently by et al. research in the the was and became in The advent of data or and became for of became not only for and other research but to the research was on and of the of the and but with time the became and studies of with the methods was the of that to address at a data on with and to a The modern of in in the and but research on was not published in the Journal of Mammalogy As technological and data on of to this in research In the the of and of has of data to of a specific as as of activity and with species of is to The of as to in nature its early to the and that could from with The in the of the Journal of Mammalogy of and a about the of using using were published in the first 10 years of the As with other research methods, in into the late 20th with and that in to the in many of for the of It was not became in the early that research using was a for that could of and in the for were the of of and for the and to see if it is not for some to have of or more that of to be often with the of (e.g., using the of the genetic and analyses, and were in this To we on two First, the to a to a mammalian and genetic provided the to data of evolution and in many cases, we the that a purely the genetic data its many our of of and methods in the mammalogy. The of these methods and to is the many mammalian in to for speciation, and has such a from so many Further, or genetic (e.g., using from and have and and many to to that we only of a years in data have impacted hypothesis-based and mammalian research and of these (e.g., were in this we more on in and the The of in the and with the of such as and for the et al. the of to more sophisticated analyses, data and of and R. and the into the modern of and to in research. the from the of and and and such as et al. and for and of and genetic In years, such as and and et al. and other have the to (e.g., et al. the of data by methods etc.) have for data to a and the of by using (e.g., 2016) has in of data through to data of these the of the or has the on research. the of to a to the were for and a through a or of for data years of those in the and and many have in It is that and other methods the of and we only how data be in the In this section, we manuscripts that were published during the three time and of time to the of mammalogy as a the of the American Society of in the middle years mammalogy and with in and and the contemporary years as we it To accomplish we manuscripts into by of or For this we the and natural history and and and and other. could for into more but we that these the types of research that and by manuscripts to these disciplines often to be a and were to entitled of a new was into the and and of some could be a or these we that the we in the we some for each time The of manuscripts published in the Journal of Mammalogy during this time were to the disciplines of natural history and and and and of were to the and most of these to a new or new and not a scientific such as and and were and to the of etc.) that would The three of during this time history and and and for of and be as the descriptive nature of mammalogy as a science at that history and remained at the of of although it a in to the time This became more with modern and research and to natural history of during this and also but was for the second of with and in the disciplines of and from previous years, studies of mammalian history and a in the of and and a and to the second other of studies In our the in the of in natural history and and and is to the for data that be to address as as to in in and data technological have given the to more sophisticated more so to the of it is genetic or and to the of the on our of it that natural history and and and have remained as the two most disciplines the history of the this and of in the Journal of Mammalogy. First, as new scientific research and to a of activity in a discipline. For example, the in and be contributed to in and the to from natural history and has remained a endeavor to in and more to be as for some in the Journal of Mammalogy. two natural history and and and have in the and of these research disciplines a of our history and one of our was to is considered to be “acceptable and contemporary mammalogy.” on the and of research in the Journal of it that manuscripts that multiple data the of modern mammalogy. natural history and and and the more disciplines of many other of to be 100 years of research emphases and technological to our of the of specimen-based of First, it is natural for a to more research as that and in and as data and a of descriptive or is in the as The the next in scientific is the of and of specific on the with a the taxonomic to a new of or and new or to more previous at some hypothesis-based research is dependent on the from specimen-based research. most on for much of research and research some on of the of research or the or data from the for most only to a of the Journal of Mammalogy to see that most contemporary studies to or data as a of the research. and specimen-based research by at the and of at a to that during the early 20th although research is for a to and as new ideas and as new technological a new generation of and hypotheses, a for specimen-based research. and at or to emphases of of taxonomic time changes in and and many other although the descriptive and specimen-based and descriptive studies not by of the most and most have to some and much of the has at a and and et al. that have the of species by in to species most of these new species be by by mammalian although the is studies by R. and many other that descriptive mammalogy is and at North American As we the directed at the of specimen-based research in and in some ways, to the of Science one of our should this we is to about was species of were and we at et al. and and the of species in of the and as the for of the of species by the time the of of the was published and 2005), the of species to The by et al. the of species to with species in new of the Journal of Mammalogy and It that the species has in First, it is that research upon and is to from the of specimen-based research. we have data data for some species but not for many For example, we a about by in the United but about from we to on specimen-based research so that we have the data to and new hypotheses. We also more in to research to mammalian Further, we to to the of in new and et al. although research has the of a genetic of the genetic in species of research The is for and other for has to to that not many of the to and specimen-based research be into the if and and et al. we have a of species to identify and have a for specimen-based research to the of Further, if we to it the for new and studies on natural history and and many other areas of natural history and data the for mammalian other research. we a of the of natural history and discuss this in more et al. and et al. the of and for natural history and the and of scientific and data to and were in a the of to and the of et al. that we in a in which and a myriad of other events our it is that the and of natural history is only to over it is our to and natural history for mammalian and most a new generation of as the and the of field-based mammalogy. how we and the next generation of if have or a or In is a of of the upon which we our research. In the modern of and techniques, one some a or research a or the for a that data and the and of and data to that data and not appear on a or of a the and with the of new to the of mammalogy it to and the that to the that some and and that be 100 years of We C. R. and for on various of this
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bradley et al. (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: