Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This subjective and highly personal commentary critically reviews the last three decades of research on British and Irish tetraploid marsh-orchids, with particular reference to narrow-leaved marsh-orchids of the D. traunsteineri aggregate. I emphasise how and why interpretations have shifted (sometimes radically) as sample sizes have increased and new sources of data have become available. Nomenclatural issues are largely ignored in order to focus more strongly on achieving optimal circumscriptions of, and ranks for, species and infraspecific taxa — essential pre-requisites for improving our knowledge of their geographical distributions and ecological tolerances, and better understanding their evolutionary origins. Although the four allotetraploid marsh-orchids listed by, for example, Clapham, Tutin & Warburg and Flora Europaea remain at the core of today’s classification, the circumscription of each species has altered substantially. The most recent genetic and epigenetic datasets to be generated required recircumscription only within the D. traunsteineri group, implying (but by no means guaranteeing) that a considerable period of taxonomic stability may ensue. Specifically, the data suggest that: (1) populations occurring south of a line from the Severn to the Wash that were previously ascribed to D. traunsteinerioides are more appropriately placed within D. praetermissa and (2) D. ebudensis, endemic to the Outer Hebrides, is probably better treated as a subspecies of D. traunsteinerioides. These recircumscriptions leave three species (D. traunsteinerioides, D. purpurella, and the exclusively Irish D. occidentalis) occurring almost entirely north of the southern limit of the last glaciation, which they probably post-date. In contrast, D. praetermissa — more similar genetically to the exclusively Continental D. majalis — had an earlier evolutionary origin and remains largely south of the last glacial maximum. Each of the four species had a separate origin, achieved by combining hybridisation with genome doubling, from subtly different ancestors ‘sampled’ from within the same two lineages of diploid dactylorchids (D. fuchsii s.l. as mother and D. incarnata s.l. as father). Thus, the tetraploids may have inherited at least some elements of their somewhat contrasting ecological preferences. Any adaptive changes that occurred following their polyploid origins may relate to the contrasting landscapes found north and south of the glacial maximum.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Richard M. Bateman (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: