Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Falls remain a major contributor to mortality, morbidity, disease burden and health and care for older people globally, with key indicators such as age-adjusted rates of fall-related hospitalisations continuing to increase year by year in a number of countries, including Australia.1 The impact of falls, even falls that do not cause an injury, can be substantial for the older person in terms of lost confidence, activity curtailment and social isolation, as well as for their family, friends and extended network. Counter-intuitively, this is occurring in the context of strong research evidence that a number of single, multiple and multifactorial approaches to fall prevention are effective in reducing the risk of falls, particularly in the community setting.2 Exercise, medication review/minimising high fall risk medications, vision correction, home assessment and modifications by a health professional, feet and footwear interventions, and cognitive/behavioural approaches have all been shown to reduce fall risk as single interventions.2, 3 In addition, multifactorial interventions, often based on a fall risk factor assessment, have also been recommended.4 Pleasingly, the evidence base is now extending to include a number of high fall risk clinical groups which, until recently, had often been excluded from fall prevention intervention trials—for example, people living with dementia. However, some adaptation may be needed for safety and effective implementation of interventions for people living with dementia, and these may be, to a degree, dependent on strong support by their carers. Incorporating the perspective of the older person (and their carer, where indicated) in shared decision-making about interventions to be implemented is also important.5 Although the challenge of fall prevention is equal or greater for older people in hospital and residential care settings, the research evidence is substantially less in these settings and warrants stronger focus and resourcing. There are a number of factors contributing to increasing fall-related hospitalisations in the context of the strong research evidence base, at least in the community setting. One of these relates to the need for contextualisation of the fall prevention initiatives relative to individual beliefs, understanding and cultural perspectives, and how these might influence an individual's uptake and sustained engagement with recommended fall prevention actions. These issues are of relevance to all older people, but can have particular relevance and need for consideration for culturally and linguistically diverse (CALD) people, and also when considering translation of research where the original research has occurred in other countries that may have different sociocultural, economic, health-care services and other factors influencing local translation. Approximately 60% of the world's population live in the Asian region. It is an extremely diverse region on many indicators, including economic (a range of low-, middle- and high-income countries), ethnic and cultural backgrounds, religion, Eastern and Western medicine practices and health services, health professional training/qualifications, proportion of population living outside major cities, filial piety, housing and environment, and language and education. This has ramifications from the perspective of fall prevention evidence being directly applicable and relevant in Asian countries, given that in a 2018 systematic review, only 9% of the fall prevention research in the community setting had been undertaken in Asian countries, and most of this was from high-income countries.6 Furthermore, the only single fall prevention interventions with multiple randomised controlled trials that had been conducted in Asia were exercise (n = 15) and home assessment and modifications (n = 2). The meta-analysis of exercise interventions conducted in the Asian region demonstrated a significant reduction in number of people who fell and number of falls.6 Other meta-analyses did not identify significant improvements in fall-related outcomes or could not be undertaken due to too few studies.6 Factors relating to cultural diversity, as described above, also occur within a single country, not just between countries. Australia, like a number of other countries, has a high and growing population of older people from CALD backgrounds. Twenty per cent of Australians aged over 50 years were born overseas in a non-English speaking country,7 and several of the larger and fastest growing older CALD populations in Australia are from the Asian region.8 Montayre et al.9 identified a number of culturally appropriate important factors to be considered to maximise the effectiveness of physical activity (an important factor in fall prevention) for older people from CALD backgrounds, including program delivery close-to-home, use of culturally familiar activities and native language instruction. Related to the ethnic and cultural factors described above, tailoring of fall prevention approaches is also required in the context of First Nations peoples. In Australia, falls occur at younger ages in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people,10 and strategies to engage and sustain participation in fall prevention interventions need to be co-developed and utilise culturally relevant approaches to improve the likelihood of success. The associated editorial by Waters and Bryant11 notes challenges, but proposes using methodologies that value both Western and First Nations/Indigenous approaches for fall prevention that are solution-based rather than deficit focussed. There is a need to step back and reflect where fall prevention research and practice currently sit within the Asia-Pacific region, and to reconsider priorities, noting that these will likely differ depending on each country. There is no doubt that the strong fall prevention research evidence base for community-dwelling older people does provide a good starting point, whilst acknowledging that just aiming to reproduce these research approaches is likely to have limited effect, without some tailoring to population and individual needs. A large randomised trial of multifactorial interventions in Malaysia did not reduce fall-related outcomes, and the authors noted the need for ‘culturally appropriate and affordable’ interventions.12 Similarly, a narrative systematic review of fall prevention trials in China has highlighted generally low-quality studies and insufficient evidence on the effectiveness or scalability of published interventions and reinforces the importance of these findings in the China context; it also accentuates the potential relevance for other low- and middle-income countries.13 Understanding local and individual context and appropriate adaptations are essential if effective research translation is to occur, and in order to achieve benefits from an individual, national and global perspective. Utilising behaviour change strategies is an important part of tailoring interventions. In summary, across the Asia-Pacific region, there is a need for adequately powered randomised trials that may utilise some of the methods from successful trials from other parts of the world, but needing to incorporate local tailoring of the methods. Without this tailoring, implementation and scaling-up approaches will be likely to have limited uptake and sustainability. Qualitative, quantitative and mixed-methods studies are required, including implementation-effectiveness hybrid trials, with associated process evaluations and economic evaluations, to optimise learning for practice from both successful and unsuccessful trials. None.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hill et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: